2 ms·
This kind of hardcore position really irritates me. Can one really say that globalism is "dead" when the very example, a TSMC factory in Arizona, is a transnat
by gumby 4y ago
This kind of hardcore position really irritates me. Can one really say that globalism is "dead" when the very example, a TSMC factory in Arizona, is a transnational investment?
The analogy is autocracy: A "Tyrant" can indeed be useful in a crisis (Churchill was as close to this point as you can find in recent history) but if they steer wrong, or if there is no crisis, history shows they are a disaster. Likewise, nativism in manufacturing can have some limited benefit (consider manufacturing for your military) but in a greater sense leads to disaster.
The way to think of this issue is resilience. You want to have a diversity of suppliers and have them have independent failure modes. Likewise you don't want local monocultures (Detroit and cars, West Virgina and coal, the loss of the semi mfg infrastructure by Silicon Valley) because all-eggs-in-one-basket is the opposite of resilience.
Also Westfalian boundaries are pretty arbitrary for this issue. Should California have its own solar panel industry instead of buying from China? Or would it be OK to buy from Idaho?
Silicon Valley still has quite a diversity of technical domains while SF evolved late and remained more of a monculture (and thus is losing a small amount of share to NYC, which SV is not). Is anyone wringing their hands over this? I don't think so, and nobody should be.