5 ms·
Abandoned art should enter the public domain (this is exactly what happens with intellectual property in the engineering R&D space).
by mensetmanusman 4y ago
Abandoned art should enter the public domain (this is exactly what happens with intellectual property in the engineering R&D space).
- eesmith 4y ago??? This isn't abandoned art. > The “Looney Tunes” and “Flintstones” content was licensed to HBO Max from Warner Bros. under an intra-company deal. Those licensing agreements expired at the end of 2022 and HBO Max did not renew them, as it seeks to reduce content expenses. Warner doesn't seem to be abandoning those episodes.
- xsmasher 4y agoHBO is owned by Warner Bros/Discovery now. Seems like it would make licensing easier. Unless they're going to "rent out" their valuable properties to other streaming services, and only keep the dregs on HBO Max?
- filmgirlcw 4y agoNo, it's more like they don't think the current price was worth renewing on HBO Max and could use that money for other content. But they'd be willing to license it to someone else (probably less than what HBO Max was paying, but that's still weirdly a win) if possible. Under AT&T, the whole idea was to keep basically everything created or owned by Warner Bros. under the HBO Max brand, no matter how much more they could be making if they licensed Friends or Big Bang Theory or whatever to Netflix or Disney or Apple or whoever. Because they saw that as an incentive to get subscribers. Now that subscriber growth has largely flattened (at least in the US), they are rethinking that idea for properties that don't bring them a lot of subscribers or that don't have a lot of views. Other streamers probably have zero interest in picking most of this stuff up because they have all gone all-in on producing all of their content in-house and have their own budget struggles, but they could do international licensing or license to FAST (free ad supported streaming television) services in a roll-up. Or they could just not have the content on streaming if they are going to have to pay for it. Vault it up. Which is a real shame, of course, but this is why some of us have continued to buy physical media or iTunes downloads.
- yrro 4y agoDefine 'abandoned'? The copyright owner is within their rights to 'rest' their property for a period to increase its value.
- AussieWog93 4y agoThey honestly shouldn't be, though. This is by definition a market failure.
- t0suj4 4y agoExcept it's the government standing in the way of supply meeting the demand.
- fortyseven 4y agoGross.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThat’s a hack. Many would love to do that in my field (materials R&D) due to the increased monetary gain, but that is harming-society behavior.
- EvanAnderson 4y agoThe usual response to this is: Let’s make copyright terms shorter and charge exponentially-increasing fees to renew the registration. Works that continue to have value to rights holders will justify their registration expense. Works that don’t have value will return to the public domain. It sounds like a good idea to me but I don’t see it having any chance of it happening.
- LocalH 4y agoRentseeking the public culture.
- derbOac 4y agoI guess I disagree that should be within their rights? Seems like a "reasonable people can disagree" thing to me. I'd just define it as "not making property available for licensing or purchase for X amount of time" or make them subject to lawsuits for not making good faith efforts to license or sell the property. Seems tractable to me, just not necessarily something easily defined in a HN thread.