3 ms·
A non profit prison should in theory be able to out compete for profit prisons because they don’t need to bake profits into their bids. They could then use tha
by Retric 4y ago
A non profit prison should in theory be able to out compete for profit prisons because they don’t need to bake profits into their bids. They could then use that surplus to have more humane conditions.
However that argument applies to other industries, but charities haven’t taken over the world because the profit motive is surprisingly effective at motivating both people and organizations.
- Tostino 4y agoYou are entirely ignoring the revenue generating portion of slave labor in this analysis.
- Retric 4y agoNo, if a private prison is paying a prisoner 0 to X$/hour the the charity might only be able to pay that same person 1$/hour more because the surplus for that labor is finite. However, that’s still an improvement.
- mannykannot 4y agoFor-profit prison systems effectively split the profit between the company and the government, by bidding lower than an ethical provider could (even if we assume no backroom deals, which is a dubious assumption to make.)
- Retric 4y agoSplitting the profit between the prisoners and government is arguably more ethical than splitting it with a private company and the government while shafting prisoners. It’s an interesting ethical question imo. Charities don’t operate third world sweatshops, but because they don’t the conditions are worse in third world sweatshops. So, if a charity wanted to improve worker confirms in the third world should they run a sweatshop?
- mannykannot 4y agoSure, in general, but when the profit comes from shafting the prisoners to the point of diminishing returns, I feel there's little room for that argument. The sweat-shop example seems somewhat quantitatively different, as treating the workers better adds value for a sufficient number of consumers.