3 ms·
Bizarre article that thinks the rise of worker power through unions might be bad for the Left?
by pjc50 4y ago
Bizarre article that thinks the rise of worker power through unions might be bad for the Left?
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoThe politics of your average blue collar worker, union or not, is very far from what comes out of the mouth of your average white collar left leaning type on pretty much every issue except possibly union stuff (and abortion stuff which varies wildly depending on where you propose on drawing the policy line and is a pretty low priority to your average blue collar worker in general) if the particular blue collar worker swings that way on that issue. So yeah, the left having to cater to blue collar people is bad for the people who care about the stuff the left is currently prioritizing.
- joenot443 4y agoI don't think that point was being made even at all. The article is trying to illustrate that the politics espoused by the wealthy and influential left is actually profoundly different and often times at odds with the personal positions held by working-class individuals.
- MilStdJunkie 4y agoIn the U.S., there's a not-entirely-mistaken perception that the Democratic Party abandoned organized labor in the Clinton era, starting with AR Labor Reform Bill of 1978 and climaxing in NAFTA. This Democrat "triangulation" - social left + blacks + structured finance - has been the DNC model for a while. According to some. Post-2008, it's obviously got problems with some of its bits. Often missed in this analysis: the intensifying ethnonatalist streak of American labor, and the problematic (if historic?) union involvement of organized crime and its natsec enablers. Theoretically Luciano was on payroll to help stop communism, but patsies have a disturbing tendency to turn into leaders of the organization they are supposed to be infiltrating. Both Hitler and Stalin being good examples of this.
- kmeisthax 4y agoIt's not bad for the Left, but potentially catastrophic to a Democratic Party whose party consensus is based off neoliberal economics and plenty of "don't talk about class, talk about race". Of course, this is also balanced out by the fact that the Republican Party has no clue where to go post-Trump (or, hell, post-Romney). They can't even get internal consensus on electing a House speaker. I'm pretty sure this article's author has an axe to grind against both left-wing politics and the DNC, though. The article's premise relies on the idea that a good chunk of the Democratic Party virtue-signals progressive causes to avoid criticism of their labor practices. That's true, but not the whole story - the Republican party is similarly paralyzed by the donor class. The underlying problem is that SCOTUS kicked the legs off of election finance rules in the name of the 1st Amendment. First they said money can be speech (reasonable) and then said there's no justification for contribution limits (wtf no). So now corporations regularly outspeak everyone else. Both parties are ideological zombies made up of call center employees who regularly moonlight as Senators and Representatives. This gives rise to "anti-partisan" issues; where both parties agree to kill "common-sense" or "everyone agrees on this" kinds of bills that would harm the donor class interests. Think about how much of a problem it has been just to get decent right-to-repair legislation going, just as an example.