5 ms·
If language models take over text content, content creators will flee even quicker into creating video content. There's already a trend where younger people ten
by wongarsu 4y ago
If language models take over text content, content creators will flee even quicker into creating video content. There's already a trend where younger people tend to prefer video for being more "genuine", and now it might become a sign of "human made" for a couple years. Also easier to monetize, and easier to build parasocial relationships, so all around a plus for creators. Too bad I prefer text.
- ikt 4y agocould it somehow get access to the subtitles and then use them to answer queries? also i hope this comes to ecosia, would like to experiment and try it at least
- jadbox 4y agoExactly, and many bots exist today to mine user videos for the automated subtitle information. In other words, there's no escaping GPT from learning from any kind of medium.
- throwaway09223 4y ago> " could it somehow get access to the subtitles and then use them to answer queries?" It's not even necessary - computers are already excellent at understanding spoken words. Have you tried automatic captioning recently? Half the inputs to my phone are already voice, not text. Video is a harder problem, but it's not too far behind.
- belltaco 4y agoI prefer text too but I feel like that's mostly because the videos are not information dense on purpose. They expand to whatever the youtube algorithm prefers at the time, which is about 10 minutes now. Ironically, tiktoks are more information dense but the search is completely useless.
- bronco21016 4y agoI’m finding more and more that the information density isn’t there because the video content is actually just an infomercial for a “course”.
- throwuwu 4y agoNope, there are already several services transcribing the audio content of video so expect that to be ingested too. You’ve seen the video suggestions with timestamps in google search right?
- wongarsu 4y agoOh, I'm aware ofhow well video transcription works. Once the lower-hanging fruit are dealt with, video content will absolutely flow into language models. But still, the video component is a key differentiator that AI can't easily mimick right now (at least not to a level where we can't tell). So users that want a personal opinion instead of a GPT-generated text are likely to turn to consuming videos.
- ren_engineer 4y agothere are already custom AI avatars and text to speech, there are already people using GPT to create text and then using other services to create the audio and dynamic videos at scale
- xhkkffbf 4y agoExactly. Several of the highly ranked YouTube videos that were recommended to me recently were clearly made by some AI doing a mashup of imagery with some text spoken by some text-to-speech algorithm.
- forbiddenvoid 4y agoI think we're very close to the point that even video won't be confirmable to be genuine. If it could even really be said to be so now. (Instagram/TikTok are the most performative/contrived content platforms these days)
- ______ 4y agoI think the push to video and away from text is a net failure for accessibility and usability, at least for reference use cases. My example: as a woodworker, I'm often curious about the details of a particular joint or the usage of a particular tool. The great amount of content on YouTube is helpful, but it's incredibly inefficient to have to seek through a bunch of filler or unrelated content to get the answer I need. Of course, that's "increased engagement" so I'm not surprised it's what is commercially more viable.
- all2 4y agoThat sounds remarkably similar to how recipes are shared in blogs. There's a huge amount of story, and then at the tail end there's the recipe. It's all for engagement, but I'm never engaged. If I'm looking for a recipe, I want to know the recipe so I can make it. I don't care about what the blogger did last weekend or in college.
- lowbloodsugar 4y agoI read that the recipes are actually bullshit. Written by content farms eating instant noodles, not anyone remotely involved with a kitchen.
- webinvest 4y agoGoogle* how long to pressure cook white or brown rice and you’ll see widely differing answers. Like shots all over a dartboard. They can’t all be correct — it’s just rice. I wonder if many of them care more about CPM rates and page visits than actual recipe accuracy. *or Bing, DDG, Kagi, etc if you prefer although I haven’t tried.
- harshalizee 4y agoI would somewhat disagree with that. My household eats rice on a daily basis and the timings for different kinds of rice varies wildly. Basmati, Sona masuri, jasmine, risotto, jeera samba rice have very different water and rice measures. And that's just white rice! Other rice variations are a whole different ball game.
- mola 4y agoSo regressing to a fully oral culture... Odd times
- jredwards 4y agoBut one that can be catalogued and relayed by robots.
- jsphweid 4y agoThe digital world is the native environment for the AI race we're creating. In that world us biological humans are relatively slow and inferior. And if this "handing the intelligence baton to machines" trend continues then "regression" to our more native communication forms feels natural and inevitable.
- taftster 4y agoThat's some interesting insight. Thank you. When I read your comment, I was envisioning us all sitting around fires in caves with animal skin togas talking about the latest HN post (which presumably was Carl scribbling down something on the rock wall).
- anigbrowl 4y agoGood, the less I have to see of their clickbait and the more time my competitors waste watching videos the better. Video has its uses and when it's good it's very very good, but most of the time it's terrible dreck that steals people's time using cheap emotional manipulation. I've been thinking about training an ML model to detect those 'Pick Me!' poster frames that highlight the e-celeb presenter making some kind of dramatic reaction face and just filter them out of search results. This is partly what happens when SEO types combine with black box algorithms; the lowest common denominator content starts to swamp everything else, a kind of weaponized reversion to the mean.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]