4 ms·
>If could practically avoid having my information sent to bad actors they would be incentivized to treat my data with care. who are the "bad actors" in this ca
by gruez 4y ago
>If could practically avoid having my information sent to bad actors they would be incentivized to treat my data with care.
who are the "bad actors" in this case? Equifax? Whoever equifax sold the information to? Whoever equifax got the information from?
>This is an example of where good government regulation can be introduced (giving consumers the option to opt out) rather than what I would consider bad government regulation (trying to specify how the companies should behave directly).
As the parent poster has mentioned, you can already "opt out" by not getting a loan. I agree that it'd be nice if some government regulation allowed to you to have your cake (ie. get loans) and eat it too (not have it reported), but there are two obvious problems:
1. One man's "private information" is another man's free speech. Why should a company be prevented from making true statements about its business dealings with you? You can leave nasty yelp reviews for businesses that have behaved inappropriately. Why shouldn't businesses be able to leave nasty credit reviews for individuals that failed to make payments?
2. On more practical level, opting out might put you in a high risk pool. Part of the enforcement mechanism for repaying loans is that if you don't, your credit gets wrecked and your life becomes harder. If you opted out of credit reporting, that's one enforcement mechanism that a lender wouldn't have, and therefore will adjust accordingly. Going back to the yelp analogy, imagine if yelp allowed businesses to opt out of reviews. Would you want to go to such a business, all else being equal?
- falcolas 4y ago> you can already "opt out" by not getting a loan Just wanted to comment on this to say: This is impossible. The reason why it's impossible is subtle because it comes from a source you'd not expect: Utility payments (power, gas, water, sewer, cable, internet, satellite, etc.). Utilities are always charged and paid for after they're delivered, and are thus loans and reported to the credit bureaus. Also, credit bureaus don't just report on loans/debts. They also report on public proceedings that may or may not have financial consequences. And your employment record is also reported by many company's HR departments to these same bureaus. So, short of going Ted Kaczynski (and even he had enough of a public presence to probably also have a credit report), you will exist in all of Credit Bureaus' databases.
- adrr 4y agohttps://joindeleteme.com/blog/how-to-remove-yourself-from-experian/ https://joindeleteme.com/blog/how-to-remove-yourself-from-ex... Outside of loans that will opt you out of Experian selling your data. You should also opt out from your bank that sells your financial transactions to Bloomberg so hedge funds can front run earnings and business’s who can determine if your a big spender or not.
- bombcar 4y agoYou can avoid the utility thing but it's hard. One way is a landlord who does NOT report - there are more of these than you'd think; many single-family home landlords are so small they don't really bother. You can also do some trickery with companies (LLC or other) but the lawyer costs and annoyance may be high. But utilities are setup to bill companies with basically no credit (worst case you deposit or pre-pay). Experian claims utilities don't report unless you don't pay: https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/can-unpaid-utility-bills-appear-on-your-credit-report/ https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/can-unpaid-utili... but I don't know if I'd trust it, and they obviously "reserve the right" to do so.
- tjrDL6MjB2Zwwa 4y ago> Experian claims utilities don't report unless you don't pay: https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/can-unpaid-utili https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/can-unpaid-utili... but I don't know if I'd trust it My experience is that this is true. I literally have no credit, as in, reports from all 3 credit agencies returns with nada. mid-40's and I made this decision in college, and don't regret it. I certainly have utility bills. There may be exceptions out there, but not in any of the municipalities I've lived in over the years.