CF is my DNS. Not sure if I had the proxy enabled. I was able to re-configure everything and it started working. I made a reminder to check around the 65 day ma

CF is my DNS. Not sure if I had the proxy enabled. I was able to re-configure everything and it started working. I made a reminder to check around the 65 day mark to see if it successfully renews. I suspect what may have caused the issue is I have multiple fly hosts on subdomains, but each subdomain had a wildcard certificate against the root (*.example.com).