3 ms·
Never actually played any of these games, but I’ve always appreciated the story that the setups tell, it seems so much more real-world than chess somehow. Like
by bee_rider 4y ago
Never actually played any of these games, but I’ve always appreciated the story that the setups tell, it seems so much more real-world than chess somehow. Like we must imagine that it was pretty rare for two perfectly matched armies to meet on the field of battle for an honorable fight until one side’s leader was captured. But I’m sure there were plenty instances where the local chief or ruler of some sort pissed off everybody in his hall, looked at his loyal guards and said “Ok my dudes, let’s get me out of here.”
And the variants shown on Wikipedia tell how universal a story it is… it is like you have in kings, princes, and chieftains in halls big and small, which they’d suddenly not like to be in.
- patates 4y ago> it seems so much more real-world than chess somehow. Like we must imagine that it was pretty rare for two perfectly matched armies to meet on the field of battle for an honorable fight until one side’s leader was captured A thing that kept me frustrated as a child: What's a bishop doing in the battlefield and how come he has infinite range? Then I started playing AoE2...
- bee_rider 4y agoApparently in the historical Indian version, the non-noble units were infantry, cavalry, chariots, and elephants, which makes a bit more sense. Edit: a funny note, “rook” appears to come from the Persian word for chariot. Which makes a whole lot more sense than the little bird that shares the English name.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThanks for bringing this up, it motivated me to read most of the Wikipedia article. I agree - unlike perfectly symmetric battlefield of chess, the story of a larger force surrounding a smaller force defending a key leader is something that did and does happen all the time. Personally, I never felt that much drawn into chess, or other classical board games, or video games with rock-paper-scissor mechanics, precisely because of the symmetry. I understand that it does crystallize the logical puzzle / challenge of the game, but at the same time, I've always found asymmetric games much more enjoyable to play. I suspect it's because they allowed me to delude myself that I can apply some real-world tactical into it, instead of actually getting good at the game. But hey, I enjoyed (and still do) this delusion as a casual player.
- bee_rider 4y agoIt is pretty abstract still, but I wonder if it could we a way to get a young heir thinking about small-unit tactics while bored in some Nordic winter.