3 ms·
> And do you need them for small, high-trust areas? OSHA would disagree, and even racetracks have rules. I think a lot of developers on HN just have a problem
by pixl97 4y ago
> And do you need them for small, high-trust areas?
OSHA would disagree, and even racetracks have rules.
I think a lot of developers on HN just have a problem dealing with the fact the rules are going to be applied to them. If you become an owner of a company your engineering rules go away, but then you have all the regulatory fun of a business owner trying to make a living and selling things at the same time. Working for a larger organization tends to have benefits like steady pay, but in return they ask for you to justify your expense and it's very possible the people asking for justification have no idea exactly what you do.
- ironmagma 4y agoOSHA is not the ultimate authority, it's just one country's solution to the problem. I don't have a problem with rules being applied to me, I just see it as dysfunction that any organization gets to the point that they need a significant set of rules. The more rules, the worse the dysfunction, typically. Exceptions include life-critical applications, where the entire existence of the company hinges on stripping human error from the product. But even then, more rules ≠ less problems. This even works introspectively; it's a bit like fitness tracking. Is a little bit of data helpful? Yes. But who is out there reading into every time they got sick and missed a few thousand steps, or thinking about every utterance and flatulence during sleep and how it signals an overall moral failing needing to be addressed? People with mental disorders, that's who.