5 ms·
Louisiana now requires a government ID to access Pornhub
- greggarious 4y ago>Motherboard confirmed, through a virtual private network, that Pornhub is showing people visiting the site from a Louisiana-based IP address a page that requires identity verification before entering. How'd they finangle that, every VPN I've used only let you select the country not the state?
- ru552 4y agoMy money is on a reporter friend in Louisiana let a reporter VPN into their machine.
- noman-land 4y agoProtonVPN allows you to select a State.
- greggarious 4y agoThanks I'll keep that in mind if I ever need to A/B test within the USA rather than per country.
- cvalka 4y agoMost of them allow to select exit nodes.
- chrisco255 4y agoA lot of VPNs have multiple cities available in the U.S. I usually pick the one closest to me for lower latency. Mullvad is one.
- tibbydudeza 4y agoThey probably check for Lafayette - what else is there in that hick state ;).
- greggarious 4y agoApparently there’s a parade in New Orleans every year :)
- tibbydudeza 4y agoNew Orleans is like a place displaced from the rest of the state.
- guywithahat 4y agoAs someone who started watching porn when he was 10 and wishes he hadn't, this seems like great news to me. Hopefully sites like reddit follow suit
- Tozen 4y agoWhere were the parents? That a kid was able to pull such off without the parents knowing, demonstrates that Louisiana's nanny state laws are not going to help at all. Sneaky kids with some tech knowledge (access to a VPN being just the start) are going to circumvent the state, as easily as they can their parents. What the state is really trying to do, is push unreasonable police state control over adult citizens. They are making excuses for tracking and monitoring adults, along with censoring freedom of speech and expression. > ...seems like great news to me... There are people that think it's a great idea for all the women to cover up from head to toe. And even others that feel any violations of their religious beliefs (including sexual practices) are punishable with death. The state and those seeking to impose on others can keep taking this as far as others are willing to let them.
- chrisco255 4y agoI started probably as a 12 year old but don't regret it. That being said, I think the main thing for teens or whoever to understand is that these are actors and this is purely an entertainment production. Most women are not interested in non-emotional, non-intimate sex (although a small minority is), but watching porn at a young age might give you the impression that it's the case.
- _-david-_ 4y ago> I think the main thing for teens or whoever to understand is that these are actors and this is purely an entertainment production Do you think that will be the case for the majority of preteens? Maybe once you become a teenager you can better understand, but the average age of first viewing porn is before the teenage years.
- Brybry 4y ago
- Rebelgecko 4y agoI think this will also be true for California and Texas in 2024 (not just porn, any website with user generated content)
- ericmcer 4y agoIt would actually be great, I know freedom and whatnot but raising someone through the puberty ages is really tricky right now. The social media stuff is almost worse than the porn, because banning your kid from it is blocking them from the main way their peers communicate. So you are left with the choice of letting their undeveloped brains get barraged by social media, or making them the odd one out at school.
- chrisco255 4y agoPervasive government surveillance and censorship "for the children" is not great. Personally, I'd opt for teaching my kid to be the odd one out whenever it makes sense.
- ericmcer 4y agoSo if your kid is struggling to fit in and everyone at the school talks and interacts via social media, and your kid asks if he can talk to friends via social media your answer would be to tell your 13 year old developing human who is struggling that they are gonna be the odd one out. This isn't the same as installing cameras on every corner because kids are getting kidnapped, this is the same thing as saying cigarettes/drugs/alcohol should be for people 18+ when they are old enough to decide for themselves, especially given all those things (and social media) has known negative impacts on developing brains.
- Brybry 4y agoUnless you watch your kid like a hawk then they'll be able to get cigarettes/drugs/alcohol as a teenager if they want to. A significant portion of my high school population was drinking alcohol at parties and another (smaller) portion was smoking weed. My understanding from most of my friends and relatives is that their schools were the same. In my opinion kids are far better served by being enabled to safely explore new experiences and methods on how to deal with peer pressure when they don't want to. But really that's up to each parent to decide, they should know their kids best. 18 years old as a magical line for all human beings being equally capable to decide for themselves is a bit silly, if anything 18 year old males might be at the worst time for these experiences. If we wanted a good 'average' age to group everyone into that's based more on current understanding of biology then we'd probably want something more like 25.
- meltyness 4y agoI don't like this because state/federal identification systems are woefully inadequate, and integrating it into this sort of regulation calcifies usage of the already ineffective system, and creates a lobbying interest against any improvements but I suppose there's mitigating factors. - it's a mere deterrent - it's limited regionally
- cvalka 4y agoThis is clearly unconstitutional.
- _-david-_ 4y agoIs it unconstitutional to require an id to get a gun?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cvalka 4y agoNo. But it's unconstitutional to require an id to get a book.
- _-david-_ 4y agoFirst, we are talking about internet porn, not porn books or magazines or whatever you seem to be talking about. Secondly, you are going to have to explain the difference between a book and a gun constitutionally. If requiring an ID is disenfranchisement of a right when it comes to books then it is for guns as well.
- miracle2k 4y agoThis may contain some informative details about the constitutional analysis: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brown_v._Entertainment_Merchants_Association\ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brown_v._Entertainment_Merchan... > First, we are talking about internet porn, not porn books or magazines or whatever you seem to be talking about. I have not, on the other hand, seen a free speech analysis hinge on the medium of delivery.
- _-david-_ 4y agoThat doesn't really address my point. If it is unconstitutional to ban sales under 18 of legal material then it would be unconstitutional to ban the sale of guns to under 18 year olds as well. The Supreme Court seems to have a contradiction on this topic for different rights.
- MivLives 4y agoI'd be curious if sites like Reddit will run into issues. It's 33% of the content of the site to qualify.
- ultrarunner 4y ago33% of content how? By byte? Surely this has to be defined better than that.
- MivLives 4y agoI hope it's by image count total. Then you can have just one giant high res porn image and be 99.99% porn free.
- ultrarunner 4y agoOld image slicing is new again!
- LinuxBender 4y agoAnd will people work around it by "filling" a site with 69% ChatGPT output?
- distant_hat 4y agoIf you look at it in terms of storage and depending on how you define 'porn' even sites like Google or Bing Images may be in trouble.
- tibbydudeza 4y ago33% - typical boneheaded move from the usual suspects - how is this measured and who decides this ???. Let me guess Texas and Florida will jump on this as well - will be interesting to see if this goes to the Supreme Court - afaik porn is protected as freedom of expression in the US is it not ???.
- _-david-_ 4y agoObscenity is not protected freedom of expression. "Vanilla" porn is generally not considered to be obscenity. Child porn, rape, etc are obscenity. However, just because something is protected does not mean you cannot require an ID. If that was the case then it would be unconstitutional to require an ID before buying a gun.
- tibbydudeza 4y agoThanks - Miller test. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_test
- Havoc 4y agoGovernment approved wank! Next step - drinking verification can with the other hand.
- ParksNet 4y agoI fear this will be a stalking horse for full digital identity, and eventually squashing all anonymous speech. The best solution here would be to force all adult sites to require a minimum monthly payment from a credit card. Blocks underage users and helps tackle addiction.
- LinuxBender 4y agoI agree it could be a stalking horse as things often are. Can't just boil the frogs. On the other hand I do not agree that people should require credit cards. For ages there has been a single line HTTP header that can be added to a site or even to the meta-data in HTML itself to identify adult content. A law could require all user-content sites to implement the header and require all browser apps, operating systems, mobile devices to make a best-effort attempt and requiring a parental control system that approve-lists domains that have the adult content header. A panel of the best UX designers in the industry could draft the RFC for device/browser updates and the law could reference the RFC. A panel of parents could test the beta versions. In NGinx it looks like this: location / { add_header Rating 'RTA-5042-1996-1400-1577-RTA'; } In HAProxy it looks like this: http-response set-header Rating "RTA-5042-1996-1400-1577-RTA" I do not know how to add this to Envoy or Caddy. This puts the control and liability of the approval on the parent and they don't even need to be technically savvy at all. This also puts the liability to self-label a site on the site owner/administrator and they can each have instructions in a standard location on the site how to enable parental controls in apps/devices after such a law requires devices to have this functionality created in a standard and simple way that just looks for the header. Despite being meant for adult content there is nothing stopping this from being used for user-generated content domains. The end goal would simply be to provide a method of parental controls per domain or globally. Most important, this method provides zero tracking of who is into what and does not leak financial or PII data. How to enforce this? Crawlers find user generated site, people submit user generated sites. No header? 3 attempts are made to contact the domains admin/technical contact. 4th attempt domain(s) are seized.
- cvalka 4y ago1. Your idea compelling the websites to provide the header will survive the 1st amendment scrutiny. I support this. 2. Your idea compelling the client software to respect the header will probably not survive the 1st amendment and is not really needed. Google/Apple will ship this functionality on their own. 3. Seizing domains is not universal. How will you seize an .am or .su domain? 4. One more anti porn idea to throw some meat to the evangelical base - remove copyright protection for porn. 1. Constitutional 2. Does not restrict freedom of speech 3. Removes incentives to produce new "professional" porn
- NotPractical 4y agoI think it's really important to protect children from this type of content. I'm not necessarily against these kinds of blocks but I don't think they'll be effective because there will always be extremely easy ways to bypass them (use a VPN, find a website that isn't beholden to US laws, etc etc etc). IMO the best approach is to ensure parents are technically competent and knowledgeable enough to be able to configure effective parental controls on all of their children's devices that are difficult to circumvent. E.g. iOS already has iCloud Lock which has proven to be difficult to bypass even with bootROM exploits and jailbreaks. Perhaps they should expand this level of protection to parental controls (if it isn't already).
- Thetawaves 4y agoWhy are you driven to control the information consumed by your children?
- _-david-_ 4y agoSurely you agree that certain content should not be consumed by children? Do you believe a 5 year old should be watching a gang bang?
- Thetawaves 4y agoWhy would a child watch a gang bang? I worry about vile content targeted toward children. I worry about these things showing up on his youtube feed, not a porn website.
- Thetawaves 4y agoAnd actually I'm not terribly concerned about sexual depictions anyway - thats the basic human condition.
- _-david-_ 4y ago>Why would a child watch a gang bang? Because they accidentally ran across a link and clicked on it. YouTube comments are filled with links to porn / non age appropriate material for example. >I worry about vile content targeted toward children. As do I. But I don't think targeting is necessarily the issue here. PornHub does target to children though. Their Instagram had a post about children watching porn for example. >I worry about these things showing up on his youtube feed, not a porn website. It isn't hard to mistype YouTube and since many pornsites have the word "tube" in them it wouldn't be hard to imagine they could get to a porn site.
- out-of-ideas 4y agoall this is going todo is have kids take their parents ids and use it; does not buy anything but more surveillance. same things happen when kids want a few more bucks or access to parents drugs/alcohol .. they are going to take it anyways Edit: come to think of it, wont the `Any commercial entity that knowingly and intentionally publishes or distributes material harmful to minors on the internet` be applicable to google, FB, titok,ect since their services are known to be addictive and such? All these research/articles on social media stating how it negatively affects mental states. gov-id for it all?
- cooper_j 4y agoI just don't think this is practical. Sure you will get some of these porn sites to add in this age check but there are plenty of foreign sites that will definitely not do this.
- morsecodist 4y agoI would be super curious to know how this impacts adult usage. Adding an ID verification must bounce a lot of users. I could see it maybe not mattering as much because PornHub has such a strong market position (they also own basically all of the other mainstream sites https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MindGeek https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MindGeek) but I could also see it mattering a more because people may be especially cagey about tying their ID to their private browsing habits. If that is the case this could potentially kill large sites in favor of a lot of smaller sketchier sites that are more difficult to regulate.
- Brybry 4y agoMy license is currently expired so I don't think I could even complete the process if I were willing to make an account with AllPassTrust. And I definitely don't desire or trust LAWallet. So PornHub is dead to me unless I vpn/tunnel/tor (or discover a bypass which I assume is based on some cookie values from a brief look at the JS).