5 ms·
Lots of posts here along the lines of "it's not good when you need to resort to social media shaming to get customer support", but I'll take the contrarian view
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Lots of posts here along the lines of "it's not good when you need to resort to social media shaming to get customer support", but I'll take the contrarian view, or at least explain why this dynamic exists.
The past 20 years has seen an explosion in Internet services, but a fundamental (often unspoken) quality of these services is that they must keep individualized customer support costs very low in order to be profitable. I mean, just look at Google, which has billions of end users. You can argue that Google takes in a ton of money, but it's not hard to see that if every Google user just had a single support call requiring 30 minutes of a support rep's time a year, that Google's profitability would tank (never mind the difficulty in hiring that many reps in the first place).
So all these services invest a ton into automated support and systems to ensure the vast majority of users never need support from a real human. That usually works well, except when you get some of these edge cases, and, very importantly, these edge cases are usually the worst when the customer behavior, while totally legit, "looks" pretty similar to malicious usage.
So, in that case, I'm glad that these back-channel avenues still exist when someone gets stuck in the machine. I wish there were a better alternative, but I really am at a loss to think what that could be. The social media channel essentially acts as a filter, as only things that are real problems are likely to get upvotes or lots of visibility. A trade off for users being able to get tons of value for (relatively) very cheap prices is that the "tail end" of support requests is usually pretty nightmarish.
- prirun 4y agoExcept in this case, the user was actually talking to customer support, so was already taking up their time. It's one thing to have zero customer support, like Google; I can see that saving money (though it's a shitty practice IMO). But if there is a CS dept and you are talking to reps but they're not solving your problem, wouldn't it be better to actually solve the problem instead of repeatedly spending time not solving it?
- patrickaljord 4y agogoogle is free though, stripe users pay for every single transactions.
- ecshafer 4y agoI worked at a Very Large Financial Company, doing a lot of internal automation type stuff. The cost per customer interaction was very high (we didn't really outsource many things on that side due to regulations needing Series 6/7/etc). Sending mail, receiving a piece of mail, getting a phone call from a customer, all of those really cost a lot of money, and reducing those volumes, and lowering the cost were a huge driver for us. Once you include overhead and stuff, its not unreasonable that a call center employee (especially a skilled one) is costing $50+ an hour. So someone that sends in a piece letter instead of a webform, and then calls and talks for 30 minutes, that might have cost $30-50 to process all of that. It adds up fast.
- thewebcount 4y agoBut doesn’t it take up more time (and hence money) to have a customer not be helped and keep emailing/chatting/calling/mailing repeatedly? Wouldn’t fixing the problem in the first place reduce overall costs?
- spaceribs 4y agoYou could argue that because this is a liability issue, something that drains our collective efficiency, and isn't a profit center for any business, that it should be regulated by the government to some degree. The CFPB for what it's worth has at least somewhat solved the predatory nature of certain banking practices, I've heard plenty of stories of threats to escalate to the CFPB getting real results for customers.
- bambax 4y ago> I wish there were a better alternative, but I really am at a loss to think what that could be. The alternative is to empower customer support reps to look up the cause of a problem. This would not affect general operations when everything is running smooth, but would solve the case where clueless reps keep asking for the same documents and can't follow through or actually do anything. What you're describing is how modern tech companies have eliminated support level 1. But if that was the plan, it should be followed by making all the remaining reps level 2 and giving them the proper tools and training to do their job.
- jetrink 4y agoI'd be ok with this if it were a tradeoff that I was choosing to make. Stripe withholding $400k can end a business. Google locking me out of my account can upend my life. I'd like to be able to pay the premium required to ensure that if an algorithm flags my account, I'm not going to be spending days banging my head against a wall trying to talk to a person who can straighten it out.
- Rastonbury 4y agoThe fact that a company has the power the screw up your life to the point you need to give them money is too much power for a company to have. It's like your bank making you pay to resolve fraud against you
- Matt_Cutts 4y agoThis is a pretty intriguing contrarian view. I recall fielding many such inquiries during my Google days. Of course, ideally every company (and organization) would offer fantastic customer service in every situation. In a world where that doesn't always happen, having an additional safety valve can be helpful for customers and companies alike. If something is eye-catching enough that a newspaper would report on it, or it would get traction on HN or social media, that's worth the time to dig deeper and investigate what happened. Again, it's not the optimal way to triage issues, but it's better than ignoring outside feedback entirely.
- nucleardog 4y ago> I wish there were a better alternative, but I really am at a loss to think what that could be. Figure out what it costs to have whoever is looking at the HN issues look at them and just charge that much for a executive VIP support request. Like, if I’ve got $400k locked up and CS stuck in a loop I’d happily drop $200 to have someone that actually has the power to talk to people and get the ball rolling on fixing stuff look at my request. I hate the idea that if or when I fall into one of those cracks that I may not have curated a large enough social media presence to actually have it resolved. I’d love if I could just, y’know, pay for services instead. Being willing to put some money down on it should help filter only for people that are serious and expect a ROI from the support ticket (e.g., people knowing they're committing fraud likely won't) and even if it doesn't it directly funds the support so if people want to pay you to waste your time and tell them no... well, no real loss.
- qzw 4y agoI like the idea in general, but any fraudsters would gladly pay quite a lot to have a chance of getting their hands on $400k. They can work out the ROI just as well as a legit customer. So the anti fraud aspect doesn’t ring true to me.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoI think the money shouldn't go directly to the company. This incentivizes them to keep their processes terrible. Publicizing it on HN seems more effective, and provides incentive for the companies to fix their processes, lest they be continually shamed. The problem is, it doesn't really scale as a method of resolving significant customer issues.
- kcartlidge 4y ago> I wish there were a better alternative, but I really am at a loss to think what that could be. (This is a general comment; not directed at Stripe with whom I personally have had no dealings needing support.) It's simple. If you can't provide useful customer service, then you can't provide a service at all. Similarly if you can't scale professionally, then in reality you can't (and shouldn't) scale at all. Tech scales, and customer bases scale, but the real world doesn't scale with it. Professionals with morals, and standards, and pride in what they do, should self-limit their business to what they can realistically handle. And that includes the greedy behemoths across all of tech. If they truly cared about their customers they would accept that there is a limit to how many they can provide quality support for, and artificially restrict their own growth until they've ironed out enough issues that they can release the tap and scale a little bit more. Of course financial imperatives beat both professionalism and pride in how the company operates, so that never happens. There's no technical fix. There's no financial fix. There's probably no legal fix either. It needs an attitude fix.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoYour argument basically boils down to "companies shouldn't be greedy", so I'm going to have to throw it onto the "not a realistic solution" bucket. But I also don't believe the moral lines are as clear cut as you would like to make them. The issue is that the vast majority of users receive excellent service, at a historically extremely low cost. The problems always arise at these edge cases where legitimate human behavior is often indistinguishable from malicious behavior without further information. But if a company decides to go with the solution of "we're not going to scale unless we have 100% of all these edge cases covered", that company would long be out of business from competition who is able to offer a lower priced product with better support for 99.9% of users. This type of problem is essentially the same as classic externality issues, and after reading some of the other responses to my comment, I think the only way this can be solved is with government intervention requiring some level of responsiveness so that there is a level playing field for all companies.
- kcartlidge 4y agoYou're right in it not being a realistic solution. It's a shame, but I'm not naive. Your main comment though is about requiring 100% fixes before scaling. I specifically said "until they've ironed out *enough* issues that they can release the tap and scale a little bit more" which is not the same thing, so I'm not actually advocating what is implied. I suspect I'm closer to what you yourself are saying in that argument than perhaps I made clear (sorry). With that said, I see all this as part of a larger problem. The examples of YouTube, Twitter, or Facebook come to mind. They are terrible at moderation, and the reason is that the default approach is to automate these aspects due to the scale involved. And I think that's wrong for the same reason as my original comment - if you cannot moderate at scale you shouldn't scale. The annoying thing is that they can moderate at scale, but to do that they would need to employ more humans. Which they won't do. An awful lot of what is wrong in tech is down to the willingness to scale purely by automation and not with humans, consequences be damned. Again, though, I'm not naive about the chances of it ever being otherwise.