2 ms·
Human interaction is inherently bubble-y. Nobody wants to get shouted at by people preaching stuff they don't like or feel harassed by all day long, so we seek
by vidarh 4y ago
Human interaction is inherently bubble-y.
Nobody wants to get shouted at by people preaching stuff they don't like or feel harassed by all day long, so we seek together in social groups that by and large are united at least along some axes of interests, and avoid too much talk of the topics we know are controversial within those the groups.
Some of us then sometimes seek broader forums to try to spread our groups ideas. But a lot of people actively avoid those kind of situations. Many others use different identities in different groups because they don't mesh well.
"Balkanized" servers are only balkanized to the extent people wants them to be (yes, admins can ride roughshod over users, but users can vote with their feed and migrate their accounts and follows elsewhere). Most people want to be widely federated. Some want forums where they can say things nobody else wants to listen to or wants to self-isolate (e.g. Truth Social, Counter Social and Gab all run - or at least ran, not kept up - Mastodon, but either don't federate at all and/or are widely blocked)
> A key difference in Twitter vs Mastodon UX is that users would have to make different accounts for each "Balkan country" server they join. If one server blacklists or is blacklisted they won't be able to participate in others. And this has implications well beyond US polarized politics once it reaches global scale.
If you want to participate in things so offensive to so many people that they're mutually blocking each other, then yes you either have to do that or find an instance that haven't defederated either. Or host/rent your own and not block anything other than what you, yourself choose.
With Mastodon you have that choice. With Twitter you risk getting outright banned site-wide.
- dmix 4y ago> (yes, admins can ride roughshod over users, but users can vote with their feed and migrate their accounts and follows elsewhere) This is true when you think it's about HN users as the prototypical user. But I'm just imagining having to explain to my mom why she can't participate in [X, Y, Z] set of Mastodon communities, doesn't she already have a Mastodon account? Why does she need accounts for each? Why are her old "tweets", followers, DMs, etc not available on the new server? This is a much larger barrier than advanced users can appreciate... maybe not right now but it will increasingly be in the future. Ultimately it's very possible groups of interconnected communities is a superior concept to centralized social networks. But this should be more of an obvious part of the UX w/ Mastodon. It's fine if it's properly communicated AND if porting your old tweets/accounts/followers/etc over to new servers is easy... but even then it's an adoption hazard (people avoid complexity they don't understand). Currently it's communicated as a Twitter of FB competitor, which may very likely come back to bite them (not to mention the UI sucking).
- vidarh 4y ago> But I'm just imagining having to explain to my mom why she can't participate in [X, Y, Z] set of Mastodon communities "X and Y don't like each other, so they refuse to talk to each other. Think of it like how you can't talk to people on Facebook from Twitter". People siloing themselves is not a new concept for people. Ironically, the new thing with Mastodon is that you don't need accounts for each of X, Y, Z to talk to people there even if X, Y and Z defederate from each other, as long as you can find "neutral territory". Only for a very small set of instances is this a challenge. Being used to silos seems to also be behind a lot of the confusion over having to pick a server - people end up fretting over the choice when it matters a lot less than they think. I wish joinmastodon defaulted to just suggesting a random "generic" instance, and hid the rest behind an "advanced users" button. > Why are her old "tweets", followers, DMs, etc not available on the new server? Her follows and followers are available on the new server if she moves the account. When I moved to my new instance, most followers had auto-migrated within minutes. It can definitely be made simpler, but given the number of non-technical users I've seen migrate, it's not that big a barrier. That the old posts are not I agree is an issue - it is likely to get solved, as the objections to migrating those with the rest are minor and stupid (you can migrate those too, but it requires a friendly admin willing to do a data import, or running your own instance, so for all practical purposes most users can't) > (not to mention the UI sucking). There are multiple UIs competing to improve this, before even considering the Mastodon alternatives that all can talk to Mastodon (e.g. Misskey, Pleroma), so this is improving rapidly. Personally I use the advanced interface and I think all it takes is some custom css and it'd be superior to Twitter in most ways (the advanced interface is somewhat like Tweetdeck; I run it with custom CSS that makes column widths configurable). Because of the total open nature of the API, there's far more room to get something good here than there is for Twitter, which is fairly awful.