3 ms·
Housing cannot durably be both a good investment and remain affordable.
by sokoloff 4y ago
Housing cannot durably be both a good investment and remain affordable.
- vlovich123 4y agoIt’s a fine investment in a diversified portfolio because traditionally it was a hedge in both capital and monthly cash flow, and decoupled from other asset classes. It also offered freedom where you can make improvements to the land to increase the rate of growth. There were also non-monetary investments because your lifestyle choices had certain kinds of freedoms it offered (in exchange for giving up others) So it’s definitely a good investment when it’s affordable. In current environments, it’s actually less of a good investment than how it used to be used (stable, inflation-protected hedge) because it’s more in the asset class of stock and intertwined with other asset classes. That’s good for you on the upswing (which is why you think it’s incompatible with affordability) but not so good on the downswing. Also high volatility and even rapid growth isn’t something most people look for in housing and housing-related costs. In other words, people now treat housing stock the same way as company stock which does make it incompatible with affordability but it’s traditional role is a hedge in your portfolio.
- sokoloff 4y agoTypically when we say that something is a “good investment”, we mean that it’s something that increases in value faster than inflation. Conversely, for something to remain affordable over a long period of time, its price must grow no faster than inflation.
- vlovich123 4y agoAs I understand it, a good investment portfolio is one that increases in value faster than inflation. A single investment though can be at inflation or even generate slight negative returns if it's role is as a hedge to sacrifice some of your overall upside to limit your downside risk. Did I get that wrong?
- tomatocracy 4y agoHousing is also pretty unique in the range of investment options available to "normal" people in that you can get meaningful leverage without some form of collateral posting/margining requirement or ongoing covenant testing.