3 ms·
Hmm but how is that fundamentally different from peer reviewing ideas?
by skrebbel 4y ago
Hmm but how is that fundamentally different from peer reviewing ideas?
- doomjunky 4y agoOne is about ideas the other is about values.
- kubanczyk 4y ago"Peer reviewing ideas" is a bad formulation for me. It's about whether the discussion is general (valid for anyone) or specific (these people, here, now). The latter gives some weight to subjective arguments and arguments from authority, the former does not, and this is a big qualitative difference.
- tremon 4y agoPeers reviewing ideas is but one step above rubber-ducking: the peer does not (necessarily) have ideas of its own, but merely serves to verify how you've formulated yours. At least, that's my interpretation.