4 ms·
> Because nobody wants one. That’s not an understatement. That is an understatement. "People" have talked about a Moon colony for a long time. Even before ther
by lapcat 4y ago
> Because nobody wants one. That’s not an understatement.
That is an understatement. "People" have talked about a Moon colony for a long time. Even before there were Moon landings.
The primary difference is that a Moon colony doesn't have a billionaire propagandist.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> "People" have talked about a Moon colony for a long time Talk is cheap. People are working on Mars.
- lapcat 4y agoNo, there are people working on rockets and talking about Mars. Not the same thing. When is the Mars launch? What's the schedule? It's 100% vaporware.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> there are people working on rockets and talking about Mars…it’s 100% vaporware Methane engines and atmosphere-agnostic propulsive recovery are far from vapourware. It’s not a launch schedule. But that’s a straw man requirement for “working on” something.
- lapcat 4y ago> It’s not a launch schedule. But that’s a straw man requirement for “working on” something. It's not a straw man when you don't trust the word and good faith of a modern day "Music Man".
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> not a straw man when you don't trust the word and good faith Then don’t. Do you dispute that those technologies exist, and were developed by people dreaming of colonising Mars? The “when is the Mars launch” standard for “working on” something is a straw man because, by that definition, nobody is working on fusion energy or Alzheimer’s disease.
- lapcat 4y ago> Do you dispute that those technologies exist You're talking about rocket technology. I already said, "If the goal was simply to visit Mars, that might be viable." The question is a permanent, self-sustaining Mars colony, where the biggest problem is not "Methane engines" but rather breathing oxygen, drinking water, eating food, not getting irradiated, not getting poisoned, not having circulatory problems, reproducing, and surviving in general. > people dreaming of colonising Mars Interesting that you use the word "dreaming".
- a2800276 4y agoI've been dreaming about getting dirty with young Cleopatra. Expect a working time machine any day now. All I'm currently missing are a flux capacitor and working out some details.
- jboy55 4y ago>I've been dreaming about getting dirty with young Cleopatra. Get in line, plus the benefit of time machines is that you don't need to wait for them to be developed.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Interesting that you use the word "dreaming" Intentionally. Hackers dream. I have a background in aerospace engineering. That doesn’t mean I know how to solve the problems of permanent habitation. But it gives me a sense of where the edges are, and while some problems are super difficult (toxicity) others are wildly exaggerated (radiation) and none are blocking. Moreover, many of the processes we’ll need to develop have obvious counterparts on Earth, most interestingly, energy and fuel generation. The author of the article wants an annual JWST or Cassini. I’d love that. But we aren’t getting it. De-funding Mars means going back to a post-Apollo NASA budget.
- jboy55 4y agoCome on, didn't you hear? Musk said in 2016 a meaningful number of people would be on Mars in 4 years. He has since extended that.... 2 years.
- giantrobot 4y agoSpaceX doesn't seem to have done any work on actually living day to day on Mars. Not even colonizing, just living. Where's the airlock that will reliably blow the perchlorate filled dust off spacesuits? A toilet that will work reliably and not fill a ship with aerosolized feces? Shit how about an actual static demonstrator for a Martian lander version of Starship? A working model methane processor demonstrating that fuel could be generated from Mars' atmosphere and stored for the duration of a launch window. I'm sure they've got some engineering schematics for some of those things or re-warmed NASA papers about those topics floating around. But talking about Martian colonies without talking about the things that would just keep a couple of people alive is just bullshitting. You're serious about an endeavor when you want to talk about the boring aspects of it. Talking up the exciting aspects is just bullshitting.
- dotnet00 4y agoThey're still working on the means to get there - which will set the limits on everything else - so it's pretty ridiculous to be arguing that they aren't serious because they haven't gotten to the rest of the work.
- lapcat 4y ago> They're still working on the means to get there - which will set the limits on everything else It doesn't. The Martian environment sets the limits on everything else. You could drag the entire Earth over next to Mars, and people still couldn't live there. The irony is that the hypothetical "What if the Earth became uninhabitable?" is effectively the same as "What if the Earth became just like Mars?"
- giantrobot 4y ago> so it's pretty ridiculous to be arguing that they aren't serious because they haven't gotten to the rest of the work Not in the slightest. SpaceX's proposed Starship design has known mass and envelope limits. All of the required support systems can be designed with those limits (or subset thereof) as part of the constraints. In fact now is the best time to start designing those because it can inform design criteria or mission profiles for Starship. Having those as handwave-y unknowns while talking about colonies is just absurd. A manned landing on Mars requires they have months worth of reliable support infrastructure available. None of that is just going to appear. It all needs to be built and landed with or before humans. It needs to be repairable with tools on hand. It must power on an be functional on Day 1. You're not serious about landing people on Mars let alone building a colony without talking about the "boring" infrastructure that will keep everyone alive.