3 ms·
It seems strange to include the Mini. As it is more of an Intel Mac for those who somehow still need Intel macOS for whatever reason. The memory capacity is lim
by ksec 4y ago
It seems strange to include the Mini. As it is more of an Intel Mac for those who somehow still need Intel macOS for whatever reason. The memory capacity is limited in ARM Mac. So if you want high capacity memory you go to Mac Studio.
And with Mac Studio, which brings us the next question. What are the Market Mac Studio couldn't compete with Mac Pro. If it is not powerful enough now, will possibly another doubling of LPDDR6, that is 512GB with 1.5TB/s of bandwidth with M3 Ultra be enough?
The only market I could think of right now is Audio Professionals with specific Plug in Sound Card. Could that market not be served if Apple had made a few more Thunderbolt 4 port available?
- pjmlp 4y agoThe market of VFX, which without an Mac Pro, might end up going back to Windows or custom built Linux desktops, like many Hollywood studios did when migrating away from SGI, and Pro wasn't still an option.
- spookie 4y agoI assume the tile based rendering architecture is the biggest footgun in the new Apple SoC's. It just doesn't scale with a lot of polygons. I don't see how they can solve this either.
- dagmx 4y agoTile based rendering wouldn’t matter for VFX work. They use path tracing. Nobody is really using rasterizers except for viewports, where it’s rare to be pushing so many polys that you’d bog down the GPU first (you’d almost always hit memory limits or CPU limits first dealing with that many transforms). I’m not sure I agree that a TBDR is bad for high poly counts. There’s nothing inherent to the architecture that I can think of that would limit it for pure polygon work. Usually the biggest hold up is full screen effects that need to work on the entire buffer but those are rare for VFX.
- dagmx 4y agoVFX has largely been on Linux workstations since the demise of SGI. There’s never really been a Mac presence at the workstation level at those studios. Windows is already in many studios due to VR or Virtual Production work, since Unreal Engine kind of sucks on anything that isn’t Windows, and the same goes for VR. However there are a few areas that Macs are used heavily and where I don’t think Apple need to be worried: - artists that need to use Adobe products or anything non Linux. Macs offer better Linux like workflows for pipelines since it’s Unix like, so is favoured for pipeline integration and macOS has much better colour handling than windows. So you’ll see in house concept artists, matte painters and the like on macs. VFX editors tend to be on macs for the same reason. Those are the folks that a Mac Pro would be handy for. - dailies review boxes. Macs again are better for playback and the arm macs are so quiet they’re perfect for a review room. More RAM is always welcome here. - coordinators and producers are almost always on Mac laptops. They’re unparalleled for battery life in a compact body. Plus since macs need to be supported for the above two use cases, it makes sense to use them as well. - conform machines to handle media conversions often are macs. Though this depends greatly on what formats are being used
- eole666 4y ago"macOS has much better colour handling than windows". How is that ? Do you just mean apple screens have a better color calibration when you get them ? Or the OS come with some tools to handles colors in some ways Windows can't ?
- dagmx 4y agoWindows has fairly poor colour management throughout the OS. If you stick to apps that are specifically colour managed, and manage your own screen profiles, it’s fine, but compare it to the Mac where: * you get much better EDR/HDR support at the OS level, so it tries to handle perceptual EDR ranges when apps switch to EDR. * the OS itself has better management for colour profiles for the screen (also better refresh rate management when it comes to common film rates) * Macs come with P3 colour handling for their first party displays https://support.apple.com/en-ca/HT210435 https://support.apple.com/en-ca/HT210435 , and while you can colour manage a windows/Linux machine post facto, it’s nice to have a system come with a good baseline that reflects their screen properties. For example, coordinators don’t need colour accuracy BUT it does help when their laptops present it well. Most desktop users would use an Eizo instead. * safari does a better job than chrome/Firefox at handling embedded image colour metadata , and also managing EDR colour. * similarly Preview, QuickTime and Finder are better at respecting embedded colour profiles and EDR where applicable than Windows Media Viewer and Explorer. Most of this can of course be replicated on Windows, but you have to go out of your way to do so. Plus you’d still lack the macs EDR handling that is great for review sessions etc… macOS doesn’t cover everything of course. Images with custom LUTs still need their own viewer apps, but I can’t emphasize how nice it is to have much more trust in what you’re seeing and reducing the mental friction while doing a lot of your ancillary work outside specific apps. It’s not perfect, but so much better then Windows where it’s a crapshoot what colour you’re going to see depending on how you view it.
- zozbot234 4y ago> will possibly another doubling of LPDDR6, that is 512GB with 1.5TB/s of bandwidth Will DRAM really scale to that extent at the device fabrication level, though? We're already seeing limits to scaling with SRAM.
- ksec 4y ago>We're already seeing limits to scaling with SRAM. I am assuming you mean the transition from TSMC N5 to N3. Which was expected. N2 with GAA will get some density improvement.