4 ms·
I graduated high school in 2009 and the top schools definitely weren't taking in students with a 3.6 GPA. In fact, I'm not aware of any school in the top 50 tha
by godelski 4y ago
I graduated high school in 2009 and the top schools definitely weren't taking in students with a 3.6 GPA. In fact, I'm not aware of any school in the top 50 that asked for anything under a 4.0 (AP/IB programs enable GPAs above 4.0). Right now I see sites saying that the average Harvard GPA is 4.18. Berkeley is lower but I know plenty of people that got rejected with high GPAs (I know two people that had a 4.8 -- the top you could get in my school -- that were rejected from several top schools).
I say this because two things. First, it is clear that there are things other than GPA that admissions are accounting for. It is a bit unclear what these things are. It would be nice to know how they are extracting signal from noise (and it is clear that this is a very noisy system, though we often don't admit this). Second, if these are actual averages, there's clearly some other aspects that are heavily weighted in that process. The four that would be the most obvious to me are legacy, affirmative action, sports, and students who don't have access to AP/IB programs. These are clearly not meritocratic aspects (lack of access to better programs like AP/IB would imply that these signals aren't meritocratic because meritocracy isn't exactly equitable in accessibility. Or do all these schools know exactly how good each high school is and their inflation rates and variance rates?).
I really think as we're learning more about how people learn that we learn that the signals are extremely noisy and may not even exist. Students from poorer backgrounds may need extra care[0] but they still do pretty well[1]. So how do you measure someone that has potential from a poor school? How does this differentiate from measuring someone that has potential but not the opportunities from median or rich schools? (environment is a big factor in success)
I really just have a lot of questions here and I really do think we should be discussing how noisy this system is. A question I want to ask is: if I randomly select a person from the population and give them a Harvard (or top tier) education, will they be more successful than if they went to a college they could have gotten into based on their merits? If the answer is "yes" (and I think there's good reason to believe this is true) then maybe all these measurements don't really mean much and we're just reading tea leaves. (I think there's some signal but I just don't know how much. I'm also not an expert. Thanks for listening to my ted talk)
[0] https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2022/11/16/klapper-privileged-poor/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2022/11/16/klapper-privil...
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/college-mobility/harvard-university https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/college-mobilit...