7 ms·
> The reason people want to colonize Mars is because it solves the problem of an extinction event on earth wiping out all of humanity (assuming the Mars colony
by lapcat 4y ago
> The reason people want to colonize Mars is because it solves the problem of an extinction event on earth wiping out all of humanity (assuming the Mars colony eventually becomes self sustaining).
Life on Earth survived the mass extinction event 66 million years ago, obviously, otherwise we wouldn't be here now. The dinosaurs were wiped out, but the dinosaurs had nowhere to hide and were completely unprepared for the asteroid impact. It's important to keep in mind that the Earth after the asteroid hit was still vastly more livable and conducive to life than Mars is now. Mars is more hostile to life than a big asteroid impact, because Mars has no habitat to start with. Mars has no benefit whatsoever to humans as far as Earth disaster survival is concerned, except for the fact that Mars is not Earth.
A much better plan to avoid extinction is multifold: (1) Stop destroying our own environment, duh. (2) Get rid of nuclear weapons. (3) Stop killing each other in general. (4) Invest in asteroid detection and deflection. (5) Build shelters on Earth capable of surviving disaster, such as underground. It also wouldn't hurt to (6) Stop being afraid of vaccination.
We've got everything we need here already: normal gravity, breathable atmosphere, food, water, raw materials, people. It would be sooooooo much easier to build disaster shelters on Earth than to permanently populate Mars. The difference in difficulty level makes Mars a total joke in comparison.
As a species, if we can't even get our shit together on Earth enough to stop polluting, stop killing, stop the threat of nuclear war, and vaccinate against contagious diseases, then we have no hope of long-term survival anywhere, because of our own stupidity. You can forget living on Mars, a massively hostile environment, if we can't do it right here on Earth, which was practically made for us.
- dento 4y agoColonizing Mars is going to be easier than solving tragedy of the commons.
- lapcat 4y agoHow can you bring humans to Mars without also bringing human nature, i.e., human flaws? We'll wreck Mars quicker than Earth, because Mars is already a wreck.
- justinclift 4y agoWouldn't it be more practical to do the "spreading to other worlds" thing at the same time as "fixing human nature"? We don't know if human nature can be "fixed" (in a positive way), so stopping other things until that's been done sounds a bit silly to me.
- lapcat 4y agoIt's not a question of starting or stopping; whether we start or stop seems irrelevant to me. The point is that humanity has been "coddled" by the Earth, because we were born and evolved here, but we won't be coddled by Mars, and thus the Mars project is doomed to failure, since we're already failing on Earth, in a vastly more favorable environment. What's the point of a "backup plan" when the primary plan isn't even working?
- jsmcgd 4y ago> What's the point of a "backup plan" when the primary plan isn't even working? The whole point of a having a backup plan is for when the primary plan isn't working :S
- lapcat 4y ago> The whole point of a having a backup plan is for when the primary plan isn't working c/when/if When your primary plan isn't working, you fix that first. Ideally, the backup plan is never needed. If your house is on fire, you don't start building a second house, you put out the damn fire. Also, it would be pretty dumb to put a backup in place more dangerous than the original. It would be like building your second home inside a volcano.
- jsmcgd 4y agoYou can't wreck a wreck. Mars can only be improved by humans.
- lapcat 4y ago
- jhanschoo 4y agoYou forgot the /s
- bnralt 4y agoIt seems easier because Mars proponents often focus on the technological challenges (which are indeed great, if not insurmountable), while ignoring the human challenges. The challenges from human nature are going to exist on Mars just as much as they do on Earth; things like warfare don't suddenly stop existing just by shifting people to Mars. People act like Mars would be a place to keep people safe from nuclear war, but destroying a Mars colony from Earth is trivial compared to creating one. If one looks at the history of colonies (attempts to colonize the new world, for instance), we see that they often fall apart socially even in situations where they're in a place with much more resources than they had back home. Humans aren't dwarf fortress type automatons that can simply be handed whatever necessary job is needed and mindlessly go about their day for the rest of their lives. No one has been able to manufacture a functioning mini-society, and every attempt has ended in spectacular failure. It seems crazy to think things will suddenly work if we drop the people in a place devoid of almost all resources and entirely hostile to life from Earth.
- m4rtink 4y agoMaybe the group will actually work together if the other option is certain death? :-)
- jboy55 4y agoHumans will still be the ones colonizing Mars, the same humans who would theoretically make Earth uninhabitable. If we humans can't stop destroying Earth, we have no chance in making a Mars colony successful.
- subradios 4y agoHuman progress is the act of changing the environment to suit our needs. Flippantly using "stop destroying our environment" brings to mind a pastoralism that was triumphant in the 90s but is basically unworkable. Your suggestion requires degrowth, and degrowth would entail a humanitarian disaster of epic proportions
- lapcat 4y ago> Flippantly using "stop destroying our environment" It wasn't flippant. Global warming is one of the greatest dangers facing humanity. > degrowth would entail a humanitarian disaster of epic proportions We have no choice, because growth already entails a humanitarian disaster of epic proportions.
- subradios 4y agoIt is flippant. "Net zero" has already been an ally to the Russian government in their war on Ukraine. Energiewende was the renewable transition that primarily offshored responsibility to Russian natural gas and coal when plants weren't running, assuming that the renewables would grow and balance out. That didn't work so well, and now a European heat wave is saving European lives. People need heat, and light, and to compute. The developing world cannot wait for net zero carbon energy, and the developed world cannot just stop all useful human activity to pursue climate goals. The rhetoric around this is if we "just" had better politics, if the oil and gas lobby weren't such villains, if conservatives weren't sticking their heads in the sand we would be able to make it to net zero while "only" sacrificing things we don't care about, like big gas guzzling pickup trucks. We are finding out that no, we can't. Continuing down this line of rhetoric is flippant, or perhaps glib. There's hope though, even if you believe that climate change will end humanity (it won't) - the status symbol cars are electric, more consumer cars are electric, renewable deployment is proceeding apace and we even have developments in fusion and SMRs. That's how we win - not with the Extinction Rebellion, but with new people doing diligent work to produce higher and higher standards of living at less and less cost. Fuel costs money, and nobody wants to use it if they don't have to - economics will eventually win, because the best low or no carbon energy sources require almost no operational cost due to lack of constant fuel input.
- baq 4y ago> (1) Stop destroying our own environment, duh. I agree except this doesn’t seem possible neither politically nor economically… launching people to Mars really sound easier
- lapcat 4y agoLaunching is the easy part. Living is the hard part. Might as well launch them into the sun.
- oblio 4y ago> (2) Get rid of nuclear weapons. This is tricky. Both because for better or for worse, they do provide a certain military equilibrium, and also because you know, it's probably a good idea to have them around, at least to a certain degree, if the Xel'naga decide that creating us was a bad idea. Not that nuke might not be sort of like throwing rocks at an advanced civilization, but it's not like we'd have anything better...
- m4rtink 4y agoNukes can also serve as propellant! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsion) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propuls... Which could also help with the second issue - say an alien elephant invasion. ;-) (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Footfall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Footfall)
- runarberg 4y ago> Nukes can also serve as propellant Not as of now. The outer space treaty[1] forbids nuclear explosions in space. I don’t think this treaty will be revised until it is made obsolete by a total elimination of these weapons of horror (e.g. by another treaty[2]). So if you want to see nuclear explosions used as propellant in space (which honestly isn’t such a bad use for them) then I recommend you petition your government to sign and implement the UN ban on these world ending weapons, if they haven’t already. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outer_Space_Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outer_Space_Treaty 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_on_the_Prohibition_of_Nuclear_Weapons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_on_the_Prohibition_of_N...
- m4rtink 4y agoI kinda feel this would be worked out one way or another when someone is in possession of a fully fueled Orion space ship with couple thousand nuclear charges on board.
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y agoI'm unimpressed with the concept of Orion. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_lightbulb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_lightbulb is more inspiring to me.
- philwelch 4y ago> A much better plan to avoid extinction is multifold: (1) Stop destroying our own environment, duh. (2) Get rid of nuclear weapons. (3) Stop killing each other in general. (4) Invest in asteroid detection and deflection. (5) Build shelters on Earth capable of surviving disaster, such as underground. It also wouldn't hurt to (6) Stop being afraid of vaccination. That all sure sounds simple enough if you handwave over all the inherent complexity, but by that standard so does colonizing Mars, and yet colonizing Mars also sounds like a fun adventure. In particular, (2) and (3) are working at cross purposes here—nuclear deterrent is the primary thing that has prevented a great power war from happening since 1945. Also, (4)—asteroid deflection—could provide a safeguard for earth, but could just as easily be used as a weapon of mass destruction. (1) is a slogan and not a concrete plan. How do you plan to provide food, energy, housing, and health care to eight billion people? Environmental issues are a question of tradeoffs and cost-benefits. Windmills are a hazard to birds, hydroelectric dams are a hazard to fish, solar and batteries require mining rare earth metals, and so forth.
- lapcat 4y ago> That all sure sounds simple enough if you handwave over all the inherent complexity I didn't say it was simple. I believe what I said: "we have no hope of long-term survival anywhere, because of our own stupidity." > nuclear deterrent is the primary thing that has prevented a great power war from happening since 1945. A sad statement about humanity. Which is why I said we need to get our shit together. Do we bring nationalism and nuclear weapons to Mars? How soon after settlement until the first Martian war starts? Could a Martian colony even survive a war, if the life-sustaining infrastructure is attacked? Or do they do it in the style of Star Trek "A Taste of Armageddon", with simulations and disintegration chambers? > How do you plan to provide food, energy, housing, and health care to eight billion people? How do you plan it? Hunger, power outages, homelessness, and lack of access to health care already exist. > Windmills are a hazard to birds, hydroelectric dams are a hazard to fish We're already killing birds and fish in many other ways more deadly.
- jboy55 4y ago>Do we bring nationalism and nuclear weapons to Mars? How soon after settlement until the first Martian war starts? Could a Martian colony even survive a war, if the life-sustaining infrastructure is attacked? Would a small Mars colony survive a single jilted lover aiming for the ultimate murder-suicide?