8 ms·
>These things happen every day, but happening to a core developer (if confirmed!) who has a deep understanding of the systems and security indicates just how fr
by gruez 4y ago
>These things happen every day, but happening to a core developer (if confirmed!) who has a deep understanding of the systems and security indicates just how fragile crypto can be (in my opinion)
Based on the other comments in this thread it looks like he didn't bother using a hardware wallet (which is literally something that's recommended on bitcoin.org[1]), and kept his wallet.dat on a server exposed to the internet. You're trying to paint a story of "well if a bitcoin core developer can't secure his coins, then who can!?!?", but in this case it looks like he was being an idiot. You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink.
[1] https://bitcoin.org/en/choose-your-wallet https://bitcoin.org/en/choose-your-wallet
edit: on twitter he denied that he kept his wallet file on a server
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoSo you’re saying that to use crypto properly, I have to secure a physical object that grants irrevocable ownership of my wealth? That sounds bad. Is there a way I can get my crypto held my an institution with SIPC insurance, the way I hold stocks at a brokerage, so I can outsource this issue to someone else who is backed by a government guarantee? (I obviously don’t expect them to guarantee the value of the crypto, just that the broker doesn’t lose it).
- s5300 4y agoNo, the only thing you need is an infallible memory.
- panarky 4y agoMaybe Luke used LassPass.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoThis was my first paranoid thought.
- gruez 4y ago> So you’re saying that to use crypto properly, I have to secure a physical object that grants irrevocable ownership of my wealth? That sounds bad. Yeah, that's how most things work in the physical world. If you want to secure a widget, then you need to "secure a physical object that grants irrevocable ownership" of it. Cryptocurrencies improve on this slightly by allowing you set up multisignature schemes, so you can get redundancy in the event of a loss. >Is there a way I can get my crypto held my an institution with SIPC insurance, the way I hold stocks at a brokerage, so I can outsource this issue to someone else who is backed by a government guarantee? If you want government guarantees, crypto might not be right for you.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y ago> Yeah, that's how most things work in the physical world. If you want to secure a widget, then you need to "secure a physical object that grants irrevocable ownership" of it. You can’t steal my house by obtaining the deed. You can’t steal my stock by obtaining the stock certificates. That’s not how it works. The vast majority of wealth in developed countries doesn’t rely on physical security to maintain ownership. We’ve collectively outsourced that function to the government and other institutions, so we don’t have to individually hire bodyguards to prevent criminals from taking possession of our homes and stealing our assets. Most people only hold a relatively small amount of wealth in forms that can by physically stolen (eg. petty cash, electronics). This means that you only need to defend yourself against a $1000 crime (stealing your TV), which is a lot easier than defending against a $1M crime (stealing your house or 401k). If crypto requires holding my wealth in a hardware wallet that can be stolen, that means I’m only going to be willing to invest the amount of wealth I would spend on a TV, not the kind of wealth I am going to allocate to stocks or bonds. Granted, crypto has utility for people who can’t use the government-backed institutions, like criminals. And in some countries where the government will steal your money, it has broader appeal. I won’t argue with that.
- bbbbb5 4y agoYou can definitely steal houses though. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-essex-59069662 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-essex-59069662 https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/news/stories/2008/march/housestealing_032508 https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/news/stories/2008/march/ho... https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/she-had-no-idea-her-home-could-be-stolen-then-she-read-her-junk-mail/2019/11/27/13569d0c-065a-11ea-ac12-3325d49eacaa_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/she-had-n... You can also steal stocks. https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/us-charges-hacker-for-breaching-brokerage-accounts-securities-fraud/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/us-charges-ha... > The vast majority of wealth in developed countries doesn’t rely on physical security to maintain ownership Indeed, it relies on far sillier things like hoping that nobody spends $100 on a fake ID and pretends to be you.
- iancarroll 4y agoThere are brokers with SIPC insurance who will hold crypto, but crypto is not covered by SIPC (AFAIK), so it’s not very useful.
- causality0 4y agoMaybe don't keep "all of your wealth" and "daily spending money" in the same bucket.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoTo clarify, the idea is I need to keep my life savings in a fire-proof, theft-proof safe?
- gnicholas 4y agoIf you're keeping all your savings in crypto, I don't think a fire is your biggest risk. /s In all seriousness, I completely agree. I'm not in crypto and this is part of the reason. There would be a huge influx of people like me if there weren't such a risk of theft (by individuals or platforms).
- reedjosh 4y agoMultisig your life savings and backup the seed phrases on stainless steal washers. You can have as many signatures as you like and require whatever quorum you like too. Maybe put some in Gold, Silver and Real Estate too. Obviously you should never put everything in one basket. Stock are to me a different class of investment from life savings type of stuff. > To clarify, the idea is I need to keep my life savings in a fire-proof, theft-proof safe? But yeah, you should definitely have a _portion_ of your life savings in a well hidden quality safe. That said, you probably only need to put one key in a safe. Hide the other and give the third to a friend or custodial service like unchained capital. For day to day use, transfer what you need to and from cold storage to hot wallets. The more wealth you have the more security you need, and you should count governmental and institutional actors in you decisions or you will ignore threats from counterparty risk, inflation, confiscation, and taxation.
- reedjosh 4y agoYou can also use multisig holdings to ease this issue. > So you’re saying that to use crypto properly, I have to secure a physical object that grants irrevocable ownership of my wealth? That sounds bad. Welcome to reality. You'll laugh now, but if you want to hold something of lasting value, that's kinda how it works. Gold is physical and requires security. Dollars lose their value to dilution. Other securities incur risks too. Multisig BTC looks downright safe in comparison
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoThis thread is actually about security and custody, not valuation. Those are different issues, but we can talk about valuation. My crypto has lost more value than any of my other investments. Since crypto (unlike stocks and bonds) doesn’t entitle me to any cash flows, and (unlike dollars) doesn’t allow me to repay any debts, why shouldn’t the value keep dropping?
- reedjosh 4y agoMeasured using fake dollars. Aka dollars made in other sham Crypto coins and loans. And now the same is happening to the regular markets since higher rates are sucking dollars from the market. My Amazon RSUs are 1/2 of my grant date and falling fast. Shtcoins gonna sht, but BTC hasn't failed in any way, and multisig makes it easier than any other commodity to secure.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoCan you go into more detail about how multisig helps? I assume one of the signatures is my hardware wallet. Who holds the other signature? Do they have SIPC insurance? What happens if my wallet is lost or destroyed?
- Thorrez 4y agoLet's say I have a 3-of-5 multisig. That means there are 5 hardware wallets. I put a hardware wallet in my safe in my house, one in a bank deposit box, and 3 with 3 friends or relatives. Now a thief needs to steal 3 of these to steal the coins. That's going to be hard for a thief to do. If a fire or natural disaster happens, it needs to destroy 3 wallets before I lose my money.
- rewtraw 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bearer_instrument https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bearer_instrument
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoMost people don’t use these anymore. Like crypto, the main utility is for crime.
- dustymcp 4y agoI still have yet to use my crypto on crime, i have however bought numerous things with various coins..
- knorker 4y agoJust for fun, or why? I try to use my credit card as much as possible for remote purchases, because if the extra legal protections.
- TimJRobinson 4y agoMost of crypto is used in Decentralized Finance, basically an open source version of the activities done on Wall Street. Very little is used for everyday goods (and you're right, why bother when credit cards give much better rewards) Have you bought options with your credit card? Borrowed money against collateral? Purchased and collected revenue rights to music? Traded oil futures? These are the kinds of things I'm doing frequently on Ethereum.
- knorker 4y agoAll of those things have better protection in traditional finance. Sure, they don't have credit card consumer protection, but they do have other protections. Unless you're using blockchain financial instruments in order to do more blockchain stuff (the circular use case), the other options are better. Trading oil futures doesn't need cryptocurrencies. And if you use it anyway then you expose yourself to additional risk not in traditional finance. E.g. the difference between FTX shenanigans hurting investors (who are now being victim blamed for "not your keys, not your coin") and anyone financially reliant on Tether shenanigans (which includes all holders of BTC) is that Tether seems to be getting away with it, by so far not being subject to a liquidity check / bank run.
- AlexCoventry 4y agoYou can use a pin to secure the device, FWIW. And back the encrypted seed phrase up. It's really not that hard.
- ec59cb1659 4y agoIt's not about money, it's about power. If you hold a physical item, you have the maximum power over it as possible. If you want to entrust someone else with it, go ahead, but at the end of the day your access to the item will be subject to their whims and those of the greater political establishment / woke clergy / corrupt and powerful.
- midhhhthrow 4y agoTrusting someone else: Well we do this every day with money in the bank, with all the risks that come with it
- reedjosh 4y agoAnd the guarantee of dilution. The banks are _securely_ creating debt based digital dollars they gain the interest on. Since they're already practically minting their own dollars they don't need to steal yours. And if for some reason the FDIC fails, then they effectively will have stolen your dollars.
- ebiester 4y agoAnd if you entrust it to a safe deposit box, then... ? And if you trust it to a safe in your bedroom, and your house burns down, then... ? Which is more likely?
- seanhunter 4y agoA hardware wallet is a physical device that stores some private keys in a tamper-proof secure element. Those private keys can be regenerated from a recovery phrase[1] which acts as a seed to regenerate the keys in a deterministic way. The hardware device is typically itself secured by means of a pin. Without the pin, the device can’t be unlocked so can’t be used, too many incorrect pin attempts will brick the device. So the answers to your questions are: 1) If you entrust it to a safe deposit box then if someone steals it, it is worthless without the pin. 2) If the safe is itself destroyed and with it the device (this is also the case if you have it in a safe deposit box and the depository is burned down or something) then the private keys (and transitively the funds) can still be recovered using the recovery phrase. So if you have securely stored your recovery phrase and are able to retrieve it even this kind of problem won’t cause the accounts to be lost. So what people tend to recommend is choosing good secure storage for your pin, keeping reasonable physical care of the device, taking the recovery phrase and splitting it into parts and storing those parts separately. If one of the parts is destroyed then you will need to urgently replace the hardware wallet, move the funds and securely store the new recovery phrase because if not you don’t have a fallback if the hardware wallet is destroyed, but otherwise you are good. [1] https://medium.com/coinmonks/mnemonic-generation-bip39-simply-explained-e9ac18db9477 https://medium.com/coinmonks/mnemonic-generation-bip39-simpl...
- Galanwe 4y ago> I have to secure a physical object that grants irrevocable ownership of my wealth That's one way, but not the only one. My preferred mean of storage is through a _vault_ smart contract, such as the "Gnosis safe". It's basically a smart contract that you deploy, and send your assets to. You can then add some of your trusted friends as co-validators and require 2/3 validations for a withdrawal. You can also set a no-validation required threshold at $X/m for the day to day. > I obviously don’t expect them to guarantee the value of the crypto, just that the broker doesn’t lose it For the record, brokers rarely (if ever) store or guarantee client money. Usually you have a custodian to hold your money (who will guarantee deposits, up to some limits), and your broker will unlock a credit line for you based on your collateral posted at the custodian. There are custodians in crypto as well, "Paxos" and "Coinbase Custody" being the most well known. They will store your money on cold wallets with very strict guarantees (shamir split of the wallet keys among anonymous holders, strong entropy guarantees on key generation, proof of reserve, etc) and unlock it upon verifying your identity with real humans. It's costly though.
- matrix_overload 4y ago>I have to secure a physical object that grants irrevocable ownership of my wealth? Not really. Can be a file copied across dozens of public places that is well-encrypted (say AES256+Blowfish) using a key securely derived (say PBKDF2 with many iterations) from a random password you don't use anywhere else. That said, if you do that, have a system that will drill you for that password weekly, or you will just forget it. And make sure this system can't be compromised to record your password as you type it.
- mrtksn 4y agoThis doesn't help at all, it's still a single point of failure without recourse. You might be subjected to rubber hose cryptography or any of the systems you use might be hacked and your password extracted.
- puffybuf 4y agoThis is what his colleague recommended. A cold wallet that is only worked with offline. It is on an encrypted file system and can be backed up. (passphrase protected) I remember that Silk Road associated guy that was caught recently with 50000 BTC. I was wondering why he didn’t just encrypt his wallet? There is no way crypto coin will work for society at large with such requirements.
- jerryzh 4y agoSince human beings are in physical forms (at least still in 21 century), physical form has been the most secure since beginning of human civilization. Every top secret NSA holds also relies on physical objects I think.
- giardia 4y agoThe implication of your comment is that Bitcoin is developed in part by someone who acts like an idiot.
- TylerE 4y agoNot really a stretch in this case https://twitter.com/lukedashjr/status/1169615995742380035 https://twitter.com/lukedashjr/status/1169615995742380035 https://old.reddit.com/r/Buttcoin/comments/4936kw/lukejr_is_a_seriously_a_super_crazy_person_quotes https://old.reddit.com/r/Buttcoin/comments/4936kw/lukejr_is_... Dude seriously Thinks the pope isn’t catholic and the sun revolves around the earth
- TigeriusKirk 4y agoHe's always stood out in crypto, even in the early days when it was all "colorful" figures.
- DonHopkins 4y agoOMG "vrml dropouts"! ;) That's olde skul. [anon]>>>>> Does the bitcoin community realize how literally crazy this guy is? [deleted]>>>> They look the other way. He is by most accounts a talented coder who understands bitcoin's protocol better than most. His eccentricities are alternatively ignored or tolerated, as they are largely (but not always) harmless as far as Bitcoin is concerned. [deleted]>>>> This tradeoff seems common in fringe libertarian groups. There's always one guy in the group who wants to overthrow the government solely to be able to marry his cousins, and the larger group accepts it because they're not in a position to turn down his assistance. theskepticalheretic>>> Yeah but that's one hell of a faustian bargain. It wouldn't be too difficult to get a new developer up to speed, or find an equally talented developer who isn't batshit crazy. His craziness drives people away from any project he works on. Hodldown>> I think you are wrong, I think bitcoin has been looking for real programmers for years but this poor quality of losers, weirdos and vrml dropouts is the best that showed up. I think this is the highest quality a project like this gets. theskepticalheretic> Well the confounding factor would probably be that experienced high quality programmers have some historical understanding of distributed systems. When they look at bitcoin they chuckle and think "Haha, it's that silly shit from the 90's we used to use to test who had the fastest PC."
- pornel 4y agoThat's a No True Scotsman answer — it's not hard to make people keep their wallets secure, because people who got their wallets stolen don't count.
- gruez 4y agoThe opposite of "no true scottsman" is nut picking[1]. In this case, I think failing to follow widely promulgated security advice is a fairly reasonable justification to exclude him. [1] https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Nutpicking https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Nutpicking
- lazyasciiart 4y agoBecause the average person always follows security advice?
- gruez 4y agoThe average person also isn't a prominent bitcoin core developer who holds 200 BTC. If you're as exposed as this guy, I think it's fairly reasonable to at least follow the most basic of security advice.
- rini17 4y agoThat something is reasonable theoretically, does not mean it will be done in practice.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pornel 4y agoBitcoin core developer is the nuttiest of bitcoin users? The whole point is that he should be the one of most knowledgeable exemplary users.
- gruez 4y ago
- throwaway290 4y agoYour argument doesn't negate the point though...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bbbbb5 4y ago> kept his wallet.dat on a server exposed to the internet Luke has specifically denied this (before you posted your comment)
- gruez 4y agoWhere was this posted? Can you post a link? edit: if you're talking about https://twitter.com/LukeDashjr/status/1609661811455819776 https://twitter.com/LukeDashjr/status/1609661811455819776, my guess is that he's either omitting something (eg. the cold wallet was internet connected, or there was a backup of its wallet floating around somewhere), or suffered a stuxnet level attack.
- bbbbb5 4y agoIn the twitter thread the OP links to. https://twitter.com/LukeDashjr/status/1609683917644120067 https://twitter.com/LukeDashjr/status/1609683917644120067 You can easily browse through his recent tweets here https://twitter.com/LukeDashjr/with_replies https://twitter.com/LukeDashjr/with_replies
- gruez 4y agoThanks, added a correction.
- bbbbb5 4y agoYeah, my best guess is that he was owned for a while and the hackers managed to pivot into everything owns. The plan was probably to backdoor bitcoin core, but after luke-jr detected his server being compromised the hackers figured they were burned and decided to run off with whatever bitcoin they could get from him.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoHe probably run a full node and an LN node on his server, to contribute to Bitcoin network. This requires storing wallet.dat on the server, and keeping non trivial amount of coins in it.
- netheril96 4y agoI know little about LN node, but a regular full node doesn’t need a wallet. The reference implementation does come with a wallet but it doesn’t need to have any balance.
- rhaway84773 4y agoIf a Bitcoin core developer couldn’t be bothered to keep a hardware wallet, why would a regular Joe be bothered to do so. Also, how is having a hardware wallet supposed to be secure? Hardware wallets may get stolen, lost, damaged, etc. Edit: Also, the link you have shared doesn’t even allow you to choose the “New” user type option if you pick a hardware wallet, allowing you to choose only the Experienced user type option. IOW, a hardware wallet is something that’s only considered usable by someone who is experienced.
- hinkley 4y agoDoctors make the worst patients.
- sfmike 4y agoBest comment yet. Outside hospitals ridden with smokers.
- Bloede 4y agoThe original argument is still valid. It doesn't matter if he did it right or not. He got robbed and he will never see his crypto again. How on earth would anyone with less knowledge than him be able to do it right. You probably give up explaing my mom why she should have used a hardware wallet...
- sampa 4y agomost people do, apparently
- DoItToMe81 4y agoMost people aren't uploading their keys to an insecure server while painting a huge target on their heads.
- sfmike 4y agoSorry but bring a horse to water is more of an analogy for the unitiated and enlightened can he shown and not adopt. In this case they were at the highest level of crypto so not really. I think saying idiot isnt true considering what theyve accomplished in career. Sounds more like core design flaws. People want convenience with finance and hardware wallets arent convenient, so he knowingly sacrificed security for convenience.