4 ms·
Similarly this gives me pause about Ivy League MBA programs. Although a small sample size, despite their ambitions the BIPOC people I know haven’t been able to
by yieldcrv 4y ago
Similarly this gives me pause about Ivy League MBA programs.
Although a small sample size, despite their ambitions the BIPOC people I know haven’t been able to reap any professional benefits from it. Whether from access to executive roles, getting taken seriously by venture capital firms, or in their attempts to join venture capital firms. There is a level of discretion in these team forming situations that is not extended to them whether it has anything to do with their race or not, its pretty clear the upwards mobility is not coming from this credential.
For people with their own capital and leverage, it amplifies their ambition if they want. BIPOC don't really have this.
The “average salary” of MBA alumnis is not what is interesting about getting one, for me or them.
Some, or more, examples to the contrary would make it seem less like a total waste of time.
- idiotsecant 4y agoI am not an ivy league MBA person but my understanding of these sorts of things is that it's not the credential itself that's useful, but the connections you make in the process.
- yieldcrv 4y agoyes, all participants were aware of this, and yet the connections resulted in no improved professional access or ability to exchange time for food and shelter.
- threadweaver34 4y ago> the BIPOC people I know haven’t been able to reap any professional benefits from it Probably because there's almost always an Asian who's more qualified or a white with better connections. The problem is the key insight you get from a BIPOC is BIPOC tend to not have much money (set aside equity and vicious cycles for another day), so unless they're your market, you're not interested in marketing to people who can't afford your products.
- yieldcrv 4y agobut this isn't about marketing or needing a BIPOC to point out BIPOC markets? thats a really odd take, how did you start with connections and end up with consumer marketing? is this a personal experience or is this non-sequitur is a common sentiment because we need to address that as ignorance
- threadweaver34 4y agoI'm looking how diverse candidates from Ivies meaningfully differentiate themselves. Ivies admit to discriminating against Asians, so on average, a BIPOC from an Ivy will be less qualified than an Asian. Why would you hire them, then? The pitch for diversity is always that diverse teams make better decisions, but it's not racial diversity that does it, it's different lived experiences. Companies exist to make money, so how can they turn someone's insight from an underprivileged background into sales when poor people buy less? This was also in the context of an MBA program where the whole purpose is making money. It'd be different for a PM of an app where 100% reach is the goal.
- yieldcrv 4y agothanks for explaining that, I think there are some assumptions that are flawed in this decision tree. 1) the admissions into the Ivy would be biased, the education should be the same as before, as admissions into Ivy were always biased in some way. So whatever their alumni (and dropouts) were known for in that brand would still be the same. 2) aggregate better decisions due to different lived experiences doesn't mean just selling consumer products to underprivileged people. you're really going to have to work on what people mean by that, "sales to poor people" isn't the whole universe of different lived experiences, there can be other market inefficiencies with a good TAM. very similar to non-revenue based reach.
- crackercrews 4y agoSo even with all the BLM advocacy, there is no pipeline for Black people with MBAs from Ivy League schools? That doesn't fit with what I've seen in other industries. Companies fell all over themselves to hire Black people. Is this not happening in MBA-land?
- yieldcrv 4y agoread it again, its not about getting hired, its about getting capital and decision making roles that skip the corporate ladder. these have an overrepresentation of Ivy League MBAs in them with a pedigree that has nothing to do with promotions. People see the Ivy League MBA as key to this and aren’t interested in the other things an MBA can do. The jobs these disillusioned alumni have were attainable without the MBA.
- crackercrews 4y agoYour original claim was much broader: > despite their ambitions the BIPOC people I know haven’t been able to reap any professional benefits from it
- yieldcrv 4y agobecause they didn't need the MBA for the roles they did land its all part of one contiguous complete thought
- crackercrews 4y agoYou also say: > the connections resulted in no improved professional access or ability to exchange time for food and shelter. When you make such broad statements, then walk them back in comments downstream, it makes conversation unfruitful.
- yieldcrv 4y agoyou’re unwilling to view it as a coherent and related thought “improved” is the operative word that you seem to ignore or view as contradictory the MBA did not improve their work prospects, they already had work prospects. you asked for a clarification, you call the clarification backtracking do you have an actual opinion on the topic now that its more clear for you