7 ms·
Lula Becomes Brazil’s President, Bolsonaro Flees to Florida
- matheusmoreira 4y agohttps://archive.ph/YV4zO https://archive.ph/YV4zO
- sorokod 4y agoThe rat has left the ship. How do you call the place fleeing rats go to?
- chrisco255 4y agoDisney World?
- cyberbanjo 4y agoShore? At least from a boat
- balsam 4y agoParadise
- matheusmoreira 4y agoCivilized countries.
- chinabot 4y agoto be replaced by different rats once they taste the power/money. Someone once said the fact you want to be a politician should immediately disqualify you from being a politician"
- arunc 4y agoIn a democratic country, why would Bolsonaro flee if he is innocent?
- josephcsible 4y agoI get the exact opposite impression from this. If Bolsonaro were actually guilty of any wrongdoing, as opposed to fleeing phony charges by a corrupt government, wouldn't he have picked somewhere more friendly to crime than the US to flee to?
- bongoman37 4y agoThe US is pretty friendly to despots as long as they haven't done anything specifically against US interests.
- borski 4y agoMoreover, he specifically fled to Florida which has far fewer regulations than, say, CA or NY.
- jackmott 4y ago[dead]
- mannerheim 4y agoIn a democratic country, why would they imprison Lula for two years if he wasn't guilty?
- airstrike 4y agoBut he was guilty, was he not? His conviction was later annulled because the Supreme Court sided with his lawyers' appeal that Lula should have been tried in Brasilia, not the state court in Parana[1] No court has ever declared him quote-unquote "innocent". I'm not saying he should be in jail because I believe in due process, but I am also not saying "he wasn't guilty" from the perspective of the electorate Said differently, "In a democratic country, why would the electorate vote to reelect someone who was objectively guilty of corruption but is currently free due to lousy due process?" is arguably the better question to ask Preemptive dis-disclaimer: I voted for neither candidate and have no skin in the game, so to speak __________ 1. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-56326389 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-56326389
- zozbot234 4y agoIt's worth noting that Bolsonaro has conceded wrt. the election results, and does not maintain that "a landslide election" was "stolen from him". And where illegal protests have happened he has deplored them with no delay, advocating for peaceful involvement in the political process instead. Most importantly, he has not tried to shift the blame for violence coming from his would-be supporters onto "the other side".
- tway1111 4y agowith no delay? in which world do you live? https://noticias.uol.com.br/eleicoes/2022/10/30/em-silencio-bolsonaro-ja-e-candidato-que-mais-demorou-a-reconhecer-derrota.htm-media/ https://noticias.uol.com.br/eleicoes/2022/10/30/em-silencio-... also, he did a live where he did almost nothing at all to diffuse *his supporters* ( not would-be as you say, you'reclearly biased and down playing these criminals), it was a very weak speech that made zero effect.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoWhy concede? He has every right to question the election results if he believes they can't be trusted. I don't fault him for doing that after this insane election. Instead of pulling out all the stops to prove the voting machines weren't tampered with, they doubled down on it, declared the results "unquestionable" and started fining and censoring everyone who questioned. That was before the armed forces report showed the potential for a compromised supply chain attack. I see news about attacks like that posted here frequently, I think the newest post was from yesterday. In a serious country like Germany, voting machines are unconstitutional due to lack of process transparency and concerns over election integrity resulted in a new election. That's how things are supposed to work. None of this "unquestionable" nonsense.
- throwawaycopter 4y agoThe only thing insane about this election was how he blatantly disrespected the law by increasing government spending in the months prior to the election. Multiple institutions verified the results of the election system. The "armed forces report" says only that they cannot prove that no fraud happened, but they failed to find a single evidence of fraud. It's important to contextualize this properly, the armed forces were fully willing to support Bolsonaro in a coup, and only gave up because he screwed up every possible internal and external support for this. After this all attempts to "question" the electoral results were an attempt to inflame Bolsonaro supporters that were demanding a coup. I don't even like Lula btw. But your descriptions of what is happening in Brazil are just plain wrong.
- chinabot 4y agoLooks to me like one set of rats has been replaced by a different set of rats, hopefully slightly less plague-ridden.
- d_e_solomon 4y agoBrazil's politics continue to be a mess. Lula, the newly elect president, was formerly convicted for corruption and then had the supreme court set aside his conviction. Bolsonaro has also committed multiple crimes and tried to the Trump election denial-ism tactics. I feel for the folks who live under these people.
- bjourne 4y agoSince the Brazilian judiciary cleared Lula of any wrong-doing how do you know that he is guilty of corruption?
- d_e_solomon 4y agoIt was vacated on a technicality, not a matter of fact.
- bjourne 4y agoYou are implying that the decision to free Lula was politically motivated. How can you then be sure that the decision to charge Lula was not politically motivated?
- zozbot234 4y agoSo what? No matter what "side" happens to be in charge at any given time, sane people would never want to live in a country where serious concerns of due process could be dismissed as a "mere technicality". That's just a recipe for show trials.
- d_e_solomon 4y agoSo what? I didn't say he should go to jail or that the verdict should have been vacated... but I wouldn't have a lot of faith in the political process if a major political figure most likely only survived a criminal trial because of a due process issue.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago
- airstrike 4y agoLula's latest electoral win is a greatest testament to Bolsonaro's inaptitude to lead Brazil than Lula's particular merit -- not unlike Biden's victory over Trump The fact that Lula and Bolsonaro were the anointed the two best candidates out of the 214 million Brazilians alive today is the sadder, bigger-picture story here -- again not unlike the US experience But the Brazilian political system has perhaps a single advantage over its American counterpart: a plurality of political parties (ok, perhaps too many). I'm hopeful that newer parties with fresher perspectives have the prerequisite wit and werewithal to insert themselves in a more prominent position for the next electoral cycle. "NOVO" comes to mind -- a modern party with modern views on paper, but which has yet to produce a viable candidate
- potamic 4y agoI think this is a common theme all over the world where there is a steady increase in corruption with time. But really, this should be expected. Political systems across the world are now many decades old. No system can be perfect and with passing time, more and more vulnerabilities are only discovered. Players exploit these to gain power within the system. The one who manages to exploit most vulnerabilities will tend to be at the top, which means in this day and age, you need to be extremely corrupt in order to reach the top of a system. It's impossible otherwise.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoTrue. I wish we had better candidates.
- gverri 4y agoIt's really insane reading some of these comments. Specially those you know were written by a Brazilian right wing extremist. Lula's prison was illegal. Is he innocent? Of course not. I don't know a single Brazilian who I could consider "innocent". We learn from a very young age to "dar nosso jeitinho" ("make our own way"). Most that criticize Lula wouldn't even survive a simple "tax evasion" investigation. Corruption in Brazil began with the first "capitanias". The first colonies. There isn't a single "non-corrupt" government in Brazilian history. Period. If you think there was one, you haven't been reading enough. Lula was imprisoned after collusion from Judge and Prosecution. There's even a conversation from the judge suggesting prosecutors to forge evidence. Judge that went to be a minister for Bolsonaro after illegally helping him defeat Lula. All that said, Bolsonaro was one of the worst and most corrupt mandates in BR history. He could have easily been re-elected was not for the fact that he and his supporters are just DUMB. The pandemic was a huge opportunity for him that he blew because that's how stupid they are. All he need to do was show some empathy. We are Brazilians. Most of us are catholics. We believe in solidarity, in the martyrdom of christ and that the poor and the destitute shall inherit the kingdom of god. If he only visited some hospitals, cried together with some families, showed his empathy and that he cared for the people, anything could happen economy wise and he would be re-elected. But he not only didn't show any empathy, but to the contrary, he mocked people suffocating. He did everything in his power to obstruct and disrupt lockdowns. He did everything to postpone vaccine purchases. He said, I kid you not, "What can I do? I'm not a gravedigger." When confronted with the raising number of deaths. Now contrast that to Lula's speech yesterday. He cried in his FIRST speech when comparing the many long queues to buy luxury cars and private airplanes to the many people in the streets with nothing but discarded BONES to eat. Bolsonaro is a vile character. But he's only as vile as his supporters. Most of them racists, elitists and deeply uneducated people. The old Brazil that would cherish slavery. That fought against an agrarian reform that hasn't happened to this day. Can you imagine this? A continental country, whose land rights go back to 500 years ago. The same elite, the same freeloaders. For over 5 centuries. Controlling and dictating the future of the country to appease their lazy aristocrat asses.
- hashtag-til 4y agoIt’s refreshing to see comments like this. Thanks