3 ms·
> let other people pursue their epistemologies without devaluing them? I object to people citing fictions as fact. I've enjoyed reading historical novels, and
by WalterBright 4y ago
> let other people pursue their epistemologies without devaluing them?
I object to people citing fictions as fact. I've enjoyed reading historical novels, and enjoy watching historical movies. But when I know something about the history behind them, it's often clear that the facts are distorted, sometimes egregiously, to suit the creator's agenda or to make it more entertaining.
> you do not personally know how to challenge it and how to divine truth from it
That's rather presumptious, don't you think?
- maxbond 4y ago> I object to people citing fictions as fact. I would too, I don't see anyone defending the quote you highlighted though. (Though perhaps they'll show up in time, hadn't been very long). It's no more presumptuous than saying novels can't be learned from. It was meant in good faith; take as much or as little from it as you care to, and if it bothered you, I apologize.
- andrepd 4y agoThis particular work has ample contemporary accounts that corroborate its accuracy. I seriously don't get your reasoning, "some books bad => all books bad"? There are shitty occultist fiction novels in my local bookstore, ergo any historical fiction books are distorted trash? I don't get it.
- WalterBright 4y ago> This particular work has ample contemporary accounts that corroborate its accuracy. It does? There seems to be only one, which I've posted twice now, and is an easy read. Cite that one. > "some books bad => all books bad" My actual words were fictions are not citeable as historical fact.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]