3 ms·
Pretty sure, yes. What companies are "not allowed to fail"? Boeing? Maybe some big banks? Maybe Oracle, Microsoft, Apple, Intel? All right, what fraction o
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
Pretty sure, yes. What companies are "not allowed to fail"? Boeing? Maybe some big banks? Maybe Oracle, Microsoft, Apple, Intel? All right, what fraction of GDP are they?
- fbdab103 4y agoAll major airlines. Food production (farming + processors + distribution). Banking. Rail distribution. If any of these encountered existential threats, I have no doubts that the government would step in citing (reasonable) national security concerns.
- coliveira 4y agoNow add microchips and all kinds of technologies deemed to be of national interest. You also forgot the national auto industry that was bailed out from certain disaster in 2008.
- therealdrag0 4y agoExistential threat is different than good old fashion competition tho. Our businesses are clearly no where close to USSR level folly and “pretend”.
- KirillPanov 4y ago> Food production (farming You have obviously lived in cities your entire life. Farms fail all the time. Ask any banker at a branch in an agricultural area.
- smolder 4y agoI remember reading comments here previously about how bankruptcy is frequent and almost a normal part of business for the farms that prop up corporate agriculture. I got the impression it was more of an accounting trick, like Facebook being Irish, and not an indication that the industry itself is unprofitable. Are the bankruptcies you're referring to leaving people in poverty? Can you speak to what portion of them are just failures on paper, as opposed to "real" failures that lead to halted operations and force people out of farming altogether?
- gnz11 4y agoI would guess that mostly applies to small-scale farms and not the industrialized ones. OP is probably referring to the massive agriculture subsidies given out by the federal government to prop up the industry.
- KirillPanov 4y agoThe term "too big to fail" refers to businesses, not entire industries. Every industry is too big to fail. Honestly, other than entertainment, I can't think of any situation where the government would allow an entire industry to fail.
- fundad 4y agoThe ones that have to borrow money from a bank are not “the industry”. The industry got paid to destroy product to keep food prices high.
- mbg721 4y agoTo the extent airlines aren't allowed to fail, that's all post-PanAm. And TWA. And Eastern.
- Manuel_D 4y agoSubsidy is not the same as state control. The PLA straight up owns companies. In Russia, the government directly operates over 80% of railway capacity. The fact that the US government is one of the primary customers of, say, Lockheed Martin does not make it a state owned company in the same vein s the above. It's still got public stock, an elected board, and otherwise operates like any other enterprise.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThe US government just pulled out all the stops to prevent a few train workers from striking. There are a lot of big companies the feds will bail out.
- lupire 4y agoNot all the stops -- they didn't give them a decent contract.
- jongjong 4y agoState support of specific corporations extends beyond QE (bailouts). The entire money-creation apparatus favors large corporations due to cantillon effects. In high interest environment, corporations can collect interest on deposits at the Fed (newly created money). during low interest environment, they benefit from people taking out loans (also newly created money) to push up their stock prices.
- epups 4y agoThis does not mean the corporations are state owned. If all large corporations benefit from the "money-creation apparatus" as you say, they still have to compete and can fail. The US government did not dictate that Google, Meta, Amazon or Apple would overtake IBM.
- jongjong 4y agoCorporations may be on a somewhat level playing field with each other but they are given an unfair advantage relative to every other business (especially small business). Any help from the money printers can radically alter outcomes. If a large corporations is getting enough help to allow them to cut their profit margins by even 10%, that may be enough to put all their competitors out of business. Survival is often a matter of tiny differences.
- praptak 4y ago> What companies are "not allowed to fail"? I'm appalled anybody needs to ask this question after the 2008 bailouts.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rhaway84773 4y agoYou mean the bailouts which earned the government handsome profits? > In total, U.S. government economic bailouts related to the global financial crisis had federal outflows (expenditures, loans, and investments) of $633.6 billion and inflows (funds returned to the Treasury as interest, dividends, fees, or stock warrant repurchases) of $754.8 billion, for a net profit of $121 billion.[89] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troubled_Asset_Relief_Program https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troubled_Asset_Relief_Progra... And the outflows include about 30% that went to Fannie and Freddie, which were quasi govt operations, and 10% to auto makers that the govt created no mechanism to recover money from. In reality, outside of the original Bear Sterns collapse, what the 2008 financial sector basically saw was a loss of confidence which was leading to a bank run. All the govt did was provided a backstop that prevented the bank run, which is why even though the government took ludicrously low ownership stakes for the money they put in, their stakes were still highly profitable. Another example showing this, but from the private sector, was Warren Buffett getting Goldman Sachs to basically pay him hundreds of millions of dollars just to lend his credibility, which was sufficient for them to weather the environment (this was structured as a loan, but the loan was just window dressing for the fact that Buffett was saying he had trust in GS). In reality, there was always gonna be a recession as house prices went back to more realistic levels and the wrongly rated AAA mortgage backed securities were marked to market to a much more realistic number, along with the knock on effects on various portfolios that included them. What tipped this recession into a major financial crisis was Paulson forcing Lehman brothers to collapse despite bids from at least 2 other companies that would have saved Lehman, simply because of a personal vendetta. The overnight and unexpected Lehman bankruptcy sowed massive uncertainty into the markets, drove a bank run, and triggered a chain reaction of failed assets that eventually made it to AIG, and the risk of an AIG failure, was what eventually caused the crisis. Much of it could have been avoided simply if Paulson wasn’t such an asshole.