26 ms·
> Only a few states produce most of the taxes that pay for the grifters like Mississippi. That is a gross oversimplification of the US. To the point of being e
by loeg 4y ago
> Only a few states produce most of the taxes that pay for the grifters like Mississippi.
That is a gross oversimplification of the US. To the point of being essentially untrue.
- ejstronge 4y agoWhat makes the GP statement untrue? I can imagine that cash flows between the US and states are dissimilar from those between nations that originate from trade - is this your qualm?
- pirate787 4y agoThese "donor" state analyses are dishonest because they use % of state budget that's from the federal government as a key metric. This metric unfairly penalizes states that run lean governments. Further, most of this federal money is entitlement spending that's following poor citizens, like the impoverished people of the Mississippi Delta, and would accrue to them no matter what state they lived in.
- mikeyouse 4y agoImagine describing states at the bottom of education and public health standards with horrible racial disparities as running “lean” governments.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoAre they still at the bottom of the education and health standards after adjusting for income? Hint: I wouldn't be asking this question if I didn't know the answer. It's long since been established that pouring money at heatlhcare and education does not do much for improving outcomes. You need to somehow cultivate a culture of less dysfunction and money can't do that by itself. It take a sociopathical kind of dishonesty to sit there and tell us with a straight face that these states would be better if they just paid more taxes and ran higher touch governments. Even in states that want to run that way the ROI of each subsequent dollar is not great and a lot of these poorer states couldn't afford to run their states that way. It would be great if states like West Virginia could run expansive public healthcare programs like states like Massachusetts do but the money just isn't there and desire to run such a program and run it well isn't there either.
- gghhzzgghhzz 4y agoit's dishonest, because it doesn't take account of the massive amounts of wealth going in the opposite direction. People's daily lives have been financialised to an extent that there is always a transfer of wealth in the opposite direction
- int_19h 4y agoIn other states, those same people might not be so impoverished that they require the same amount of federal money to subsist. Perhaps running a "lean government" might have something to do with that?
- maroonblazer 4y agoAccording to Wikipedia[0] these states supplied >1.5% of federal tax revenues in FY2019: California-13% New York-9% Texas-8% Florida-6% Illinois-5% Ohio-4% Pennsylvania-4% New Jersey-4% Massachusetts-3% Minnesota-3% Washington-3% Georgia-3% North Carolina-2% Virginia-2% Michigan-2% Maryland-2% Tennessee-2% Missouri-2% Indiana-2% Colorado-2% Connecticut-2% [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_tax_revenue_by_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_tax_revenue_by_state
- golem14 4y agothese numbers make little sense unless you normalize to per-capita. CA and NY are probably still ahead, but less so. Then factor in people living at or below property line and so on, and after a while, it won't seem so unfair to the poor Californians.
- ensignavenger 4y agoData is a little old, but it does not appear that CA and New York are really ahead- https://www.jsonline.com/story/money/business/2017/04/17/how-states-rank-per-capita-federal-taxes/100577824/ https://www.jsonline.com/story/money/business/2017/04/17/how...
- dragonwriter 4y agoNY and CA are pretty high on that list, but this is more current, and has them even closer to the top. Given that significant tax policy changes have occurred in the interim specifically intended to raise federal taxes on taxpayers from CA, NY, and similar states, that should be unsurprising. https://www.moneyrates.com/research-center/federal-income-taxes-by-state.htm https://www.moneyrates.com/research-center/federal-income-ta...
- xyzzyz 4y ago> Given that significant tax policy changes have occurred in the interim specifically intended to raise federal taxes on taxpayers from CA, NY, and similar states, Indeed, residents of these states were underpaying federal income taxes, and the law was changed to remove the loophole.
- mnky9800n 4y agoFeel free to provide a substantive description of how it really works. https://www.moneygeek.com/living/states-most-reliant-federal-government/ https://www.moneygeek.com/living/states-most-reliant-federal...
- gghhzzgghhzz 4y agoI don't know anything about US states, but we have the same arguments here in the UK. Living outside London, there's nothing I can do in my daily life that doesn't result in a net transfer of wealth from my self, or from the public domain, into the private sector and therefore into London. Every private or public interaction I have has been financialised. be that being forced to keep a car, having children in school, getting sick, renting or owning a house. I could go to toilet in the middle of the park and that would result in net movement of wealth to London and offshore (someone would be sub-contracted to clean the park).
- ars 4y agoYou can't eat money. Those states you call "grifters" provide the food you eat, and the resources you need. The dollar value of those things isn't high - financial and other services are "expensive", but ultimately useless, they just move money in a circle, but don't do anything to keep people alive and well.
- mnky9800n 4y agoThe states that have high GDP typically have healthy food production so I don't really understand your argument. https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2016/05/25/know-where-your-food-comes-usda-foods https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2016/05/25/know-where-your-f...
- ars 4y agoReally? In an argument about money versus food you're giving me a map denominated in dollars?
- astrange 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]