3 ms·
Stopping ad fraud only hurts people trying to make money from it. Preventing web scraping is good for privacy. This is implemented in a privacy preserving way.
by charcircuit 4y ago
Stopping ad fraud only hurts people trying to make money from it. Preventing web scraping is good for privacy.
This is implemented in a privacy preserving way.
- nibbleshifter 4y ago> Preventing web scraping is good for privacy. You will need to elaborate on that.
- gattilorenz 4y agoI assume the OP means that scraping is used to collect public data, including that of individuals, which can even be linked across different websites. There’s at least a couple of services that try to connect somebody’s Instagram account to their FB/Twitter/LinkedIn etc. I assume some of those rely on scraping (+username checking), since the TOS for the APIs of those social networks probably prohibit this use case.
- charcircuit 4y agoYes, big datasets of user data can be created and sold. This user data can be joined across multiple sites to build up profiles on people. These datasets floating around can harm the reputation of a site.
- userbinator 4y agoPreventing web scraping is good for privacy It's bad for freedom. Very, very very bad. Talking about the "privacy" of what has been made publicly available makes no sense.
- charcircuit 4y ago>It's bad for freedom So are laws in the real world about stealing. >Talking about the "privacy" of what has been made publicly available makes no sense. Yes, it does. Users often wish to be able to delete or make something that was once public private. For example someone could post a picture of themselves on twitter. A year later they are no longer comfortable with having pictures of themself online so they go and delete them. Despite the user deleting them malicious scrapers will not delete them and keep those images. Another example would be setting your real name to your twitter name. Later you aren't comfortable using your real name so you change it away. Scrapers may still have your real name despite you wanting it to be a secret.
- cvalka 4y agoSo you don't believe in freedom of speech. Got it. Google should not exist and other great ideas.
- charcircuit 4y agoI never gave my opinion on privacy. Also, Google can exist just fine if they were not allowed to store private documents.
- cvalka 4y agoYou don't believe in freedom of thought or speech. Period.
- userbinator 4y agoUsers often wish to be able to delete or make something that was once public private. People also wish to be be able to do a lot of other things, but that doesn't make it right. What becomes public history must remain immutable. Otherwise you're just going to encourage a state in which those who have the power to will destroy and rewrite the past to their advantage, to control the narrative over the population. The trendy phrase "right to forget" is effectively a "right to rewrite history". It's interesting that you automatically call those wanting to preserve what could possibly be very important history "malicious scrapers".
- charcircuit 4y ago>It's interesting that you automatically call those wanting to preserve what could possibly be very important history "malicious scrapers". I am going off of twitter's view. If you store tweets locally you must listen for when they get deleted and then delete them on your end too. If a scraper is breaking twitter's rules I consider that malicious scraper. https://developer.twitter.com/en/developer-terms/policy#3.Update_Respect_Users_Control_and_Privacy https://developer.twitter.com/en/developer-terms/policy#3.Up... >If you store Twitter Content offline, you must keep it up to date with the current state of that content on Twitter.