6 ms·
Look at the U.S. Do we have Iowa holding hands with California in a mutually respectful relationship of cooperation? No, it's just a fight to control the highes
by rayiner 4y ago
Look at the U.S. Do we have Iowa holding hands with California in a mutually respectful relationship of cooperation? No, it's just a fight to control the highest level of government that has all the power so that one group can impose its will on everyone else.
- givemeethekeys 4y agoHaha. This is the dynamic of many a happy marriage :).
- ericj5 4y agoyes. it’s literally called the united states of america. at the very least, iowa is much better off as part of the union than it would be on its own
- thriftwy 4y agoCalifornia could do on its own, but any inner region if the USA (Brazil, Russia, China) would be super miserable as a sovereign state.
- tristor 4y agoCalifornia would immediately become a failed state on its own, unable to meet even the most basic needs of its residents. California MASSIVELY relies on other states for two of the most essential needs for modern civilization: water and electricity. California, ecologically, is not capable of supporting its own population independently, and short of geo-engineering at continent scale nothing will ever change that. It has absolutely nothing to do with politics, economics, or any sort of issues like that, it's simply the geographic and ecological nature of the state. Los Angeles, for example, would be impossible for it to exist without modern technology and mass importation of water, most of which comes from outside of California (although some comes from Northern California where it actually rains). Anyone, like yourself, who seriously contends that California could survive on its own independent of the United States simply does not understand how anything works, water systems, electric systems, import/export economies, globalism, money movements between coasts, investment funding and how it is structured to take investments from the US heartland and VC companies in Californian tech. Your statement is not just a gross oversimplification of a LOT of complex topics, it's blatantly untrue in /every single/ one of those topics.
- reducesuffering 4y agoSoCal will just use NorCal water along with access to ocean desalination. For residential use, there is plenty, without needing to ship out water in the form of half of the US's fruits, nuts, berries, and vegetables. Solar ramp-up is progressing well, already at 17% vs. 50% natural gas, with battery storage to eventually buffer the rest of the 15% nuclear + hydro.
- tristor 4y agoDesalination will likely be required long term for SoCal no matter what, but currently California is not capable of supporting the energy requirements of desalination to replace the water it gets from out of state. The vast majority of California water comes from out of state, less than 30% comes from sources in-state.
- reducesuffering 4y ago> The vast majority of California water comes from out of state, less than 30% comes from sources in-state. That's quite a preposterous assertion. Source? CA has ~85% coming from the Sierra Nevada watershed, only 15% is the Colorado River at the bottom. "California receives 75 percent of its rain and snow in the watersheds north of Sacramento."[0] CA is more than water self-sufficient if it loses the 15% Colorado River, but reduces the ag. water usage (80%) that ships out most of it to the rest of the states. https://water.ca.gov/water-basics/the-california-water-system https://water.ca.gov/water-basics/the-california-water-syste...
- nerdchum 4y agoDo you know how much energy it would take to desalinate water for 30 million people plus all the farms? We're talking numerous large nuclear power plant levels of energy. Have you reaf how long it takes to build a nuclear power plant?? Around a decade. So it's not as simple as just "desalinate"
- reducesuffering 4y ago
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago> but any inner region if the USA would be super miserable as a sovereign state. Would they? Would they really? Sure they'd be poorer but they'd probably just consider that a really, really cheap price to pay for not having to share a country with California (or wherever the line is drawn). Would you take a 10%-20% pay cut to get your way on almost all political issues? That's basically the bargain you're striking when you get out the map and draw a poorer but much more politically homogeneous state. I think most people would take the deal they'd do it with a smile on their face.
- int_19h 4y agoIndependence doesn't really mean getting your way on almost all political issues, though. If you're independent but economically weak, you're susceptible from all kinds of pressure from your neighbors, and quite often that pressure is explicitly political (sanctions etc).
- vkou 4y agoYes, let's look at the US. Despite all the bickering and backbiting and dysfunction in it, the overwhelming majority of its residents and polities do not want to see the union broken apart. The strongest argument against growth of the EU is, quite literally, inertia. It's not a perfect union, but it's much better for its participants than being marginalized outside it.
- Dalewyn 4y agoAs an American, I can tell you that most states generally consider each other rivals, and oftentimes bitter. Texas would like nothing to do with California other than to help knock them down some pegs, for example. But you know what? If some outsider were to pose a serious threat to any of the states, we're all going to band together and tell said outsider to get wrecked and go pound sand. That same Texas would be among the first to come to California's aid and defence. The only one who gets to dunk on Americans are fellow Americans, nobody else.
- Eric_WVGG 4y agofellow American here, re: "most states consider each other rivals," as a person who's lived all over the US, I strongly believe that feeling is in one direction. There is all this rhetoric in red-state politics, governors shipping immigrants to NYC, Texans obsessing over Nancy Pelosi, babble about "east coast values." That shit simply doesn't exist in the other direction. It's true that coastal elites harbor a lot of resentment toward "rednecks" for things like the recent abortion ruling, but… they just don't obsess the same way. Mostly they just don't think about them at all.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 4y ago> That shit simply doesn't exist in the other direction. It's true that coastal elites harbor a lot of resentment toward "rednecks" for things like the recent abortion ruling It certainly does exist when they think folks in red states are in a position to exert control over the national culture. Do you remember the Bush administration? Or the beginning of Trump’s presidency? People were pretty obsessive about him here in DC before he even did anything.
- Eric_WVGG 4y agoI'm not talking about individuals, I'm talking about masses of people. Of course blue state people hated Bush, and Trump, and Reagan… I'm talking about this weird notion that I hear from southerners that people in the city "look down on them." They don't. They don't think about them at all. I'm not sure which is worse.