4 ms·
You need to be very very very careful not to disincentivize people declaring safety issues. They should really just unwind the wrong incentive and handle it dif
by Waterluvian 4y ago
You need to be very very very careful not to disincentivize people declaring safety issues. They should really just unwind the wrong incentive and handle it differently.
- vlovich123 4y agoRandom spot checks of declared safety incidents + serious penalties for fraud (which this is if the companies are lying about safety incidents to avoid paying out compensation) is probably sufficient without changing any regulations in any meaningful way. No regulation is perfect but it’s quite surprising how effective regulations become when you start spot checking whether everyone is being honest.
- Waterluvian 4y agoAre you describing what food agencies do with their pseudorandom inspections? Because indeed those seem to work very well at a relatively low cost.
- vlovich123 4y agoSure that’s one example but I think there’s various things like this. You have to make sure that investigators can also be made undercover where makes sense (if it’s possible to obfuscate malfeasance) and rotate the inspector’s physical location (to avoid potential for corruption due to personal relationships). You always still have other corruption vectors (eg getting buddy buddy with the inspector’s boss and influencing them indirectly). It’s an unsolved problem but you can always do better than nothing.
- phpisthebest 4y agoUnder what basis do you have to claim those "random" inspections "work very well" Personally I believe they do almost nothing. Food born illness is pretty common and almost impossible to trace unless it is a wide spread outbreak. Many cities only inspect a food establishment every 2-3 years and in some cases as long as 5 years. I think reputation, and economics play a larger factor in safety then government inspections. Dirty places making their customers ill tend to close long before the government inspectors come around.
- Waterluvian 4y agoWhat country are you referring to?
- phpisthebest 4y agoGiven we are in a topic thread about the US State of NY, about a Law in NY State. I am referring to the US, and Specifically NY which has been famous for their health dept in come cases not inspecting places for years
- Waterluvian 4y agoGotcha. My only experience is with Ontario. Fair to assume we were sticking to NY. :)
- vlovich123 4y agoOk. But a state being disfunctional in a specific way surely means we should be looking externally for places where it’s not that disfunctional to figure out how to fix the disfunction. No? Am I taking crazy pills?
- mywacaday 4y agoPenalties need to include individuals and not just companies.
- autoexec 4y agoEnforcement, transparency, and accountability are critical to regulations working correctly, which is why companies lobby against them at every opportunity. If they can get a toothless regulation on the books companies and politicians can all pretend something has been done to address the problems while the people can continue to be endangered/exploited.