3 ms·
“Students talk about conflict like it’s this terrible thing,” Mallon said in an interview. “Is it that they’re afraid of [conflict], or are they lacking in expe
by giantg2 4y ago
“Students talk about conflict like it’s this terrible thing,” Mallon said in an interview. “Is it that they’re afraid of [conflict], or are they lacking in experience?"
It might also be that school and society has conditioned them to be this way. They've been told what feel about this subject.
When I went to school, fights were fairly rare, but they did happen. Usually they were minor without any serious injuries. Your punishment was usually several detentions, saying you're sorry, and your parents punishing you at home. Now, the police get called. One mistake and your life may be ruined.
Of course independence would benefit kids. Imagine being constantly watched, told where to be, told what you can and cannot do, etc. You're like an animal born at the zoo. All you know is your exhibit - a curated world with specially designed limits. You wouldn't last a day in the natural world where risks exist, but would be manageable with the proper knowledge/experience.
The main problem is that there is a lot of risk involved with that - legal risks. Whether that's someone calling the cops on an unattended child, or being responsible for any civil damages cause by a child, etc.
One additional point related to the zoo example... domestic animals are not as smart as their wild counterparts. In theory, they didn't need to problem solve since they were being taken care of. I think it's much the same for people. Take someone's phone. Now what do they actually know how to do without looking at instructions or a video?
- hef19898 4y agoThis refusal, at any cost it seems sometimes, to accept certain conflicts as being a necessary part of social interaction drives me crazy sometimes. Because without adressing the conflict, tensions will only build up until it really gets nasty.
- theshrike79 4y ago"Calling the cops on an unattended child" is so very HOA-cul-de-sac American that it's hard to even fathom for a non-American. Over here (in the Nordics) kids walk/bike to school every day. In Finland the limit is 5km IIRC, after that you get a taxi or bus ride. Kids travel alone to their hobbies, again by walking, biking or public transport. I do use Apple's Find My on my offspring, but only to see how much of a warning I need to give them to get home for dinner (are they next door or at their friend's house farther away).
- Atheros 4y ago"Cops called on unattended child" doesn't actually happen very often. It makes the news in the U.S. specifically because it is rare.
- giantg2 4y agoThis. It's not usual. However, it is still a risk in some areas.
- seneca 4y ago> Calling the cops on an unattended child" is so very HOA-cul-de-sac American that it's hard to even fathom for a non-American. It's really not. It's not something that really happens anywhere with frequency, and suburbs are the places you're most likely to see kids roaming around on their own. It's rarer than it was a generation ago, but it's still there.
- daveoc64 4y ago>When I went to school, fights were fairly rare, but they did happen. Usually they were minor without any serious injuries. Your punishment was usually several detentions, saying you're sorry, and your parents punishing you at home. Now, the police get called. One mistake and your life may be ruined. I have the opposite view to this. Why is it generally OK (not just in the USA, but many other western countries) for any kind of crime at school to be handled in-house, and swept under the carpet, when if you did the same thing on the street/in the workplace you'd get in trouble with the police?