4 ms·
That problem occurs in exactly the same way on any vote in a "normal" parliament where party affiliation determines vote. > D has a share in "voting weight", b
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
That problem occurs in exactly the same way on any vote in a "normal" parliament where party affiliation determines vote.
> D has a share in "voting weight", but no power at all. We can say this for sure
This is interesting in a different way. D's ability to vote has no power at all. That's true. You're taking a leap when you extrapolate that D has no power; by that argument, lobbyists have no power either. Is that something you believe?
- eru 4y ago> That problem occurs in exactly the same way on any vote in a "normal" parliament where party affiliation determines vote. It also occurs under most 'normal' voting systems in safe seats.
- vintermann 4y agoLobbyists have power through money and networks. If a non-pivotal voter has power, it's likewise through something else than his vote. That this is a problem with party whipping in parliaments too, doesn't mean it's not a problem.
- eru 4y agoI'm not sure party whipping is actually a problem? Btw, parties and how they work in specific electoral systems are (at least partially) a function of how general voting works in those systems. If you have a sortition system, parties might work rather differently, if they would be present at all. MPs submit to the whip's party discipline, because they need the resources of the party to get re-elected etc. Under sortition, the incentives are all different.