4 ms·
So what we should actually discuss more is how preferences are embedded. The problem with ordinal systems are that exactly the same but with cardinal systems th
by godelski 4y ago
So what we should actually discuss more is how preferences are embedded. The problem with ordinal systems are that exactly the same but with cardinal systems they aren't. I don't think a percentage system is a good way for expressing the advantage because people are going to be used to more discrete systems like a 5 star rating system. Here's a better example:
Suppose there are three candidates, A, B, C, and D. We have a strong preference for A, we like B and C equally, and strongly dislike D. How do we express these?
- Ordinal: A > B > C > D
- Cardinal (5 points): A:5, B:3, C:3, D: 0
We can see the embedding issue here pretty clearly. In an ordinal system there cannot be a means for us to express that we have no strong preference of B over C. We also can't express how much we like C over D because we're forced to place them equidistant from one another. This is a big problem because in the ordinal system we say that our preference of B over C is identical to our preference of C over D. There is a clear advantage here to cardinal systems that have a lot of downstream effects that lead to cardinal systems passing the favorite betrayer criteria -- aka strong spoiler -- (ordinal fails) and is why these systems are monotonic (ordinal systems aren't).
I argue strongly in favor of cardinal systems but I often find that people are strongly invested in ordinal systems. Unfortunately fair vote has done a great job at advocating for RCV and people get passionate about things they are not passionate about learning about. But I need to note that there are downsides to cardinal systems too. Voting systems are over constrained and so it really depends on what criteria you are optimizing for. If we strictly want the best VSE over everything else, there's ordinal systems that out perform cardinals. There is nuance here that we need to recognize and be aware of in these discussions, especially when passion is abound. We'll also see if Clay shows up. If it stays on the front page long enough he'll probably see it (hi Clay ;) He's the real expert here.
- vintermann 4y agoIt's perfectly possible to allow equality in ranked choice voting systems, so A > B = C > D. But what happens in your cardinal voting system, if D and C are the front runners in competition for a single seat? Imagine the final results were A: 30 points, B: 20 points, C: 50 points, D: 51 points. If only you had given the realistic challenger to D your full support (5) instead of being expressive in your preference and docked them 2 points. Now D will rule for another 4 years and the C supporters will call you a traitor for voting your honest preference, just like in the present system. And this scenario is easy to imagine. You usually know who the front-runners are, and because not only you, but everyone else, wants to avoid that scenario, belief about who the front runners are has a self-reinforcing effect. A scenario where you're glad you didn't award the full 5 points, though, is much harder to imagine. And a scenario where you are BOTH glad that you didn't award them 5, yet glad that you didn't award them 0, is as far as I can see never going to happen in a single candidate election.
- godelski 4y ago> It's perfectly possible to allow equality in ranked choice voting systems, so A > B = C > D. While this is easy to write down it isn't easy to tabulate. You must provide a new tallying algorithm (you'll find that important features break). > But what happens in your cardinal voting system, if D and C are the front runners in competition for a single seat? I'm a bit confused what you're asking here. There are no voting systems where a single vote/rank permutation/rating will not change the outcome of an election. To do so would mean votes are being wasted. Yes, there are people that will be upset in these situations just like people are upset in a close sports game. But unlike a close sports game we have a higher expectation that the teams that win like this are more likely to be similar. That is candidate C's voters frequently like candidate D (your ordering even suggests that despite the example ballot being from someone on the other side of the political isle). The point is to get someone that is the most representative. In the end, it shouldn't matter what a single voter's preference is, it matters what the collective preference is. That's why we vote in the first place. So that's why I'm confused. But maybe you should click on the montonicity link. You may also find this link[0] interesting. It is also extremely important that we remember that no voting system is perfect. So if you're going to put down a voting system because you've found a flaw you'll never be happy with a system unless you lie to yourself. It also means that if you're arguing with someone and point out a flaw you need to attempt to convince the person why that flaw (and others) are important in comparison to the upsides/downsides of the other competing system/s. Discussing voting systems is difficult because there are no global optima but it is also more difficult to discuss because proof by counter-example is meaningless and will only convince a novice. If you're wondering the motivation I'm giving in my arguments, click the links. [0] https://web.archive.org/web/20180721221826/https://www.starvoting.us/farewell_to_pass_fail https://web.archive.org/web/20180721221826/https://www.starv...
- vintermann 4y ago> While this is easy to write down it isn't easy to tabulate. Ranked pairs etc. have no problem tabulating it. If the change to allow equal ranking breaks some obscure metric, that's a sign the metric isn't very important. After all people can just rank everyone if they worry about it. I've read a lot about this, and I argue with the usual suspects range people every time the topic shows up. I don't understand how you don't understand the argument. You can come into situations where you'll regret you didn't min-max your choice (rank everyone 0 or 100). You can't come into situations where you say, "gee, I'm glad I ranked that candidate somewhere in between". Consequently, everyone will do that, whether it's good for the collective or not. Sure, I want what's best for society, but I'm not volunteering to have my vote diluted for the common good - especially since I know that the people I disagree with most, certainly won't do it.