3 ms·
As I noted upstream, sortition's a pretty fascinating concept. A few years ago I'd thought that the US Supreme Court might benefit by both expansion and select
by dredmorbius 4y ago
As I noted upstream, sortition's a pretty fascinating concept.
A few years ago I'd thought that the US Supreme Court might benefit by both expansion and selecting by lot the judicial panel for any given case. This would throw far more uncertainty into the outcome of any given Supreme Court case, as well as the capacity to throw the court in the benefit of one party or the other for years at a time. That's been proposed by others.
Another possibility might be to apply a similar approach to legislation, with an expanded Congress closer to the 30,000:1 constituent to representative ratio initially in the US Constitution rather than the 616,000:1 ratio presently in place. That would result in a House of 11,000 members, however.
(I'm willing to accept that this might prove infeasible, though I'd still like to see approaches enabling greater direct representation.)
What if, as with the Supreme Court reform proposal, legislative votes were based on a subset of representatives, again allocated by lot from amongst members? Again, though outcomes would over time average to partisan representation, any given vote might, or might not, favour the majority party.
One possible consequence: given the impossibility of guaranteeing a known outcome in votes, legislation might be written to more broadly consider overall views. This could avoid exremes, though it's worth noting that extremes gave rise to both highly discriminatory and civil-rights-reform practices. Some extremes seem less bad than others.
There's also the probable outcome that the locus of control would shift elsewhere. I'd still like to see some discussion of such concepts.