4 ms·
The reason for the interstate trucks is the taxation system that punishes railroads for owning their right-of-way. The trucks cause by far the most damage to th
by WalterBright 4y ago
The reason for the interstate trucks is the taxation system that punishes railroads for owning their right-of-way. The trucks cause by far the most damage to the highways, but taxpayers subsidize that with the gas tax. Trucks also do not pay property tax on the highways.
Long haul freight should be done by loading the semi's trailer onto a flat car, and picking it up near the destination.
Another myopic government decision is to try to replace the diesel trucks with electric ones, you know, for the environment. Far better for the environment would be to do away with long haul trucking and use freight trains instead, which are far more efficient. Trains also do not spread tire and brake dust all over the place, either.
- engineer_22 4y agoTrucks pay much higher tolls. Tolls are based on axles and weight.
- josephcsible 4y agoBut not nearly higher enough. Driving on roads damages them in proportion to the fourth power of per-axle weight, which is about 17,000lbs for a fully loaded semi and 2,000lbs for a car. To put that in perspective, if the toll for the car were $0.25, it'd have to be over $1,300 for the truck for it to be fair in that sense.
- nemo44x 4y agoIt will just raise shipping costs and therefore raise the cost of goods. By charging trucks more it creates a regressive tax effectively. By subsidizing them this is a way we utilize socialism to ensure lower wage people have access.
- WalterBright 4y agoThat's why move the freight by rail.
- UncleEntity 4y agoThey move a bunch of freight by rail, nobody wants to pay someone a bunch of money to drive it when they can just throw it on a train. And trains are relatively time inefficient so people in Maine couldn’t have their fresh Californian strawberries a couple days after they are plucked out of the field. Maybe people don’t deserve to have fresh produce but that’s another discussion altogether.
- WalterBright 4y agoDid you know that one of the very first uses of the first transcontinental railroad was shipping fresh California produce back east? And this was a century and a half ago.
- UncleEntity 4y agoThey still do…depends on the shelf life of whatever they’re shipping.
- WalterBright 4y agoThey used ice in the old days. Strawberries will last up to 6 days if you refrigerate them coming home from the store, I don't know how long that is since they were picked. A lot of fresh produce comes in by jet.
- UncleEntity 4y agoIt’s quite common for me to show up at a shipper in the morning and whatever I’m picking up is still in the field. I’ve even had stuff loaded straight into the trailer out of the field a few times.
- sfpotter 4y agoUh, who doesn't deserve to have fresh produce??
- Thorrez 4y agoWell the tax increase on trucks can be accompanied by some other tax decrease that mostly affects poorer people, such as a sales tax decrease or an income tax rate decrease in the lowest bracket.
- nemo44x 4y agoThe USA has possibly the best freight rail system in the world and it’s used extensively. Trucks pay a ton of tolls, licenses, and fuel tax.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe interstates are a constant stream of freight trucks. Trucks cause 4x the pollution of trains. Trucks spew tire and brake dust all over the countryside. Most of the maintenance on highways are the result of trucks, and this is paid for by taxpayers.
- nemo44x 4y agoTrucks are what get goods to their destination. Rail can only get you so close.
- WalterBright 4y agoRight. For a 3,000 mile journey, 2,998 of those miles can be by rail with the trailer set on a flatcar. The mile in and the last mile the trailer is picked off the flatbed and hooked up to the semi.
- sfpotter 4y agoIn what sense does the US have the best freight rail system in the world? Not trying to be antagonistic, here---just want to know why you think this. Regarding your other comment ("trucks get the goods where they have to go"): in other countries, such as Switzerland, many buildings (think an Ikea store) are required to be reachable by rail, in which case regional trains can deliver goods to a hub, and then local trains can take goods from the hub to the store. No need for trucks in this case.
- bombcar 4y agoThe absolute amount of freight moved by rail in the US is insane. But the US is also roughly the size of Europe and is shaped so there are many population centers far from the ocean. If you remove bulk freight it’s quite a bit of a difference but still massive. Much of European freight goes by boat and truck without much train.
- engineer_22 4y agoCan the efficiency of trains and trucks be quantified? It might make your argument stronger
- WalterBright 4y ago"On average, rail is four times more fuel efficient than trucks, and emit 75% fewer GHG emissions. This fuel-efficiency can also help to reduce transportation costs significantly, while giving the business a promotional platform for sustainability initiatives." --- google "efficiency of trains vs trucks
- UncleEntity 4y ago> Trucks also do not pay property tax on the highways. Why would they pay property tax on a highway they don’t own? What they do pay is a per mile tax that is collected at the pump and divided up to the states through IFTA. Every single mile a truck travels is taxed by some state even if it’s just using it for personal use like shopping at Walmart.
- bombcar 4y agoTaxation of electric trucks is something that hasn’t been resolved quite yet.
- WalterBright 4y agoYes, they do pay a use tax. As noted elsewhere in this thread, the tax is far too low to account for the damage caused by the weight of the truck.
- UncleEntity 4y agoPeople make the assumption that the roads aren’t designed with truck travel in mind methinks. The other option, making trucks pay their “fair share”, would just get passed along to consumers as higher prices and nothing would change. Like when fuel prices go up, truck drivers don’t eat those costs but they get a higher fuel surcharge which just gets accounted for when they’re pricing the goods on the grocery store shelves. I also don’t think you fully understand how massively huge the transportation system is in the US. Assuming they could switch over to trains and assuming you live in the Bay Area they’d just have the trains deliver to Tracy or Stockton (where all the big warehouses currently are) and still have trucks deliver to the store down the street. Same amount of trucks you currently see with the only difference being the long haul truckers now doing local work. Keeping with the Bay Area example, the last three times I delivered there two loads were going overseas out of Oakland and the third was a super small warehouse in San Leandro which didn’t even have a dock and I had to back a half mile down this tiny street — twice because there wasn’t anywhere to turn around and I was originally facing the wrong direction. I deliver to California all the time and all the warehouses are outside of the big cities. Well, except in LA but they’re just generally wrong about most things.
- someonewhocar3s 4y ago[dead]