2 ms·
> In the USA, however, freedom of speech is an absolute right. No, its not, just as conflicting affirmative grants of government power are not absolute grants.
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> In the USA, however, freedom of speech is an absolute right.
No, its not, just as conflicting affirmative grants of government power are not absolute grants.
Were it an absolute right, there would be no such thing as defamation liability, for instance.
> There are some narrow limitations (Libel, Calls to Violence), however the legislature does not have the power to add limits without a constitutional amendment
That’s true in theory, but in practice whether an exception exists and what its boundary is not a question which is resolved until after a legislatige body (federal or state) creates a new prohibition, and it is challenged. So there are potentially infinite unknown limitations that exist, but merely haven’t been discovered because a legislature has not created a law which would require them. So legislatures can provide an opportunity for courts to discover new exceptions via normal legislation, even if they can’t create them.
And sometimes, courts discover new ones in areas previously thought settled, like the 1st Circuit “discovering” a broader defamation exception for private matters than was generally understood to exist: https://www.hklaw.com/en/insights/publications/2009/04/federal-court-truth-is-not-a-complete-defense-for https://www.hklaw.com/en/insights/publications/2009/04/feder...