4 ms·
Does the U.S. consider it to be a provocation too far to equip Ukraine with weapons systems that can strike these Russian missile batteries in Russia? It is rid
by jeffbee 4y ago
Does the U.S. consider it to be a provocation too far to equip Ukraine with weapons systems that can strike these Russian missile batteries in Russia? It is ridiculous that we are tacitly tolerating this war by Russia but apparently we are afraid they will nuke us or someone.
- goalieca 4y agoCertain media is reporting strikes on airbases that are bombing civilian infra as “escalation”. There’s definitely no shortage of people who believe Ukraine having territorial sovereignty is too hardline for negotiations.
- ummonk 4y agoThere are also options for asymmetric tit for tat escalation that Russia could take. E.g. there are numerous militias in the Middle East that would happily accept high-end Russia weaponry to attack American troops.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- NickNameNick 4y agoDo the Russians have any equipment to spare? They already repatriated an s300 battery from Syria back to Russia.
- derriz 4y agoI've wondered this also. I could understand the initial reluctance for western powers to supply such weapons. But the complexion of the war, it seems to me, has changed considerably with most Russian long range weapon fire now directed at civilian targets. This Russian tactic must constitute a war crime and so I feel the case for supporting the defence against these weapons is much stronger.
- simplyaccont 4y agoMost of russian launched missiles are either airborne or launched from ships in Black Sea or Kasipan Sea. Also a bunch of iranian drones. The "only" land missile batteries in russian is S300 in Belgorode area that shoot at Kharkiv direction.
- jeffbee 4y agoThat only tangentially answered the specific form of the question. Why not equip Ukraine with anti-aircraft weapons that can threaten aircraft over Russia or anti-ship weapons that can harass targets in the Black Sea?
- simplyaccont 4y agothey shoot missiles from strategic bombers from hundreds miles away. caspian sea is even further (like thousand miles). Anti-aircraft systems or anti-ship "coast defence" systems do not work at those distances. Ukraine did bomb strategic bombers air-base that is around 350miles away, a couple of times recently, what made them relocate planes further away.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> That only tangentially answered the specific form of the question. Why not equip Ukraine with anti-aircraft weapons that can threaten aircraft over Russia Russian ALCMs have ranges of over 1,000 miles, and are launched from bombers that fly from bases hundreds of miles from Ukraine. There are no surface-to-air missiles that can shoot them down in flight from Ukraine. Ukraine is attacking the bombers on the ground with their own Tu-141 drones converted to cruise missiles. The only thing that can practically be shot down in flight (short of a sufficient air combat capability to challenge control of airspace over Russia, which isn’t happening short of a general war with the West, sending equipment to Ukraine won’t do it) are the missiles themselves, which is why Ukraine is being supplied systems like Patriot and NASAMS. > or anti-ship weapons that can harass targets in the Black Sea? Ukraine’s domestically-developed land-launched Neptune missile has longer range to the US’s longest-range dedicated anti-shipping that currently have a surface launch system, and only slightly shorter range than the ATACMS, which isn’t AFAIK, designed for anti-shipping use but might be pressed into such use, or the LRASM, which is currently only integrated with certain US air platforms. The only thing the US might be able to transfer that would provide this coverage is the just-introduced Maritime Strike Tomahawk, which I gather there are very limited numbers of in US service.
- vkou 4y agoYes, it does, just like Russia considers it a provocation too far to strike Ukraine's warmaking industry. Because that industry is located in NATO countries. Also, Ukraine striking Russia would erode international support for it, and be a fantastic domestic propaganda opportunity for Russia. There is no situation in which doing so would be to Ukraine's advantage. It can only win the war by destroying Russia's will to fight, it cannot win it by destroying it's means to fight.
- edgyquant 4y agoThe difference being that those NATO countries can beat Russia conventionally and thus Russia is trying not to have what’s left of its land forces turned to dirt. The US is trying to not hurt Russians feelings
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vasac 4y agoNATO can beat Russia, but because Russia can hurt NATO feelings with nuclear strike NATO choose to sit on their asses and leave Ukraine to fight.
- _kbh_ 4y ago> Also, Ukraine striking Russia would erode international support for it, and be a fantastic domestic propaganda opportunity for Russia. Ukraine has been striking inside Russia proper since at least April. Ukraine has every right to strike back at Russia, at Russian military installations inside Russia.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Does the U.S. consider it to be a provocation too far to equip Ukraine with weapons systems that can strike these Russian missile batteries in Russia? Maybe. I would not rule out that the real rationale is that limiting the scope of escalation of assistance serves the purpose of giving room to escalate further without crossing some point beyond that which would cross what it actually sees as “too far”. Also, Ukraine has a (limited) domestic deep strike capability using Tu-141 jet drones converted to cruise missiles, which it has used to strike deep into Russia at strategic bomber bases from which Russia has been launching attacks. > It is ridiculous that we are tacitly tolerating this war by Russia I’m not sure I’d describe it that way; while on the one hand we are limiting the kind and scope of assistance to Ukraine, and not directly intervening, the arms lift to Ukraine is pretty much unprecedented in anything post-WWII where we aren’t directly engaged. This doesn’t seem to be “tacit toleration” of Russia’s war.
- colechristensen 4y agoYes the US has publicly stated they are avoiding delivering weapons which could be used to strike inside Russia.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Yes the US has publicly stated they are avoiding delivering weapons which could be used to strike inside Russia. Which is strictly untrue; weapons the US has supplied already can strike inside Russia (and get the ability to strike further inside Russia as Ukraine has retaken territory.) It is likely that if, any real criteria regarding where it can strike is being used, its something like “systems that would be an advantage over other alternatives available to Ukraine only (or primarily) in strikes into Russia”. It’s also possible that that’s a PR position covering a different set of calculations with regard to weighing the desire to provide Ukraine superiority while limiting the acceleration of the escalatory spiral and preserving visible options for retaliatory escalation short of general war to deter new Russian provocations.