4 ms·
> it’s (in part) a recruitment mechanism for reactionary politics. Only because "progressive" politics has forced it into that role. There's nothing inherentl
by zozbot234 4y ago
> it’s (in part) a recruitment mechanism for reactionary politics.
Only because "progressive" politics has forced it into that role. There's nothing inherently wrong or problematic with a stay-at-home lifestyle if that's what you prefer and you can afford it.
- woodruffw 4y ago“Look at what you made me do” is not a generally convincing argumentative structure. There’s no particular reason why doing traditional things means you also need to dress yourself in reactionary politics. Besides, I think if you actually went out and sampled the world, you would find plenty of stay-at-home progressives.
- rubicon33 4y agoIs it possible the behaviors and "ways of life" are inherently political?
- sjohnson91 4y agoInterracial marriage was illegal in the 1950s because racists saw the existence of and normalization of black people in white society as a political statement and an attack on their way of life. It is the same reason why interracial kissing in movies was considered taboo back then.
- 0ct4via 4y agoThere's a massive difference between having the choice (and freedom) to stay at home -- or not -- as you wish, and pushing a movement which subjugates and flies in the face[1] of the very feminism[2] that gave women that choice to begin with. [1] https://mashable.com/article/tradwife-feminism-tiktok https://mashable.com/article/tradwife-feminism-tiktok [2] https://www.eviemagazine.com/post/the-problem-with-the-tradwife-feminist-dichotomy https://www.eviemagazine.com/post/the-problem-with-the-tradw...
- zozbot234 4y agoExcept that it seems a lot more people are pushing the "girlboss" lifestyle compared to the "tradwife" one. Of course, ideally, everyone would simply have the freedom to do what's best for themselves. It's not very responsive to call "girlboss" a product of modern capitalism as the Mashable article does, since one could say the exact same thing about modern stay-at-home lifestyles.
- watwut 4y agoThis literally not true. The tradwife thing is not a reaction to progressives, it is safely within conservative christian "male head of the house with authority over partner" tradition. It predates progressive politics you complain about. Progressive politics is response to that.
- zozbot234 4y agoHistorical gender roles were an efficient reaction to material circumstances of life, not a matter of politics. Men were more comfortable than women in the public sphere (which used to be a lot more contentious and competitive historically than it perhaps is today), and someone had to do all the crummy housework (unless you were in the upper class and could afford servants) so it fell on women to do that. Then the world, by and large, became a lot comfier and safer; and home appliances meant we could dispense with a lot of strenuous domestic labor. That's when it became possible for "lifestyle" to be a matter of choice.
- watwut 4y agoThat is widely ahistorical claim. Historical gender roles were as political as current and as much reaction to material life as now. Also, the roles of women and men different between social classes, periods and places, sometimes very widely. In particular, upper middle class and riches are minority of population. Poor are most frequent ... and their women work for money unless it is illegal ... and it is illegal purely because of politics and feeling of propriety, nothing material. And also, the small farms mean that everyone working in home, at field and with animals ... men do physically demanding work tho more. There is gender split, but not between "crummy home" and "work". The household produces a lot of what they need - candles, fabric for cloth, you name it. There are some gender exclusive areas and then a lot of basically work that needs to be done. Or, in mining areas, men die young. They earn more then women, but they live without sun and die and then you have women having to earn for them and children - that is where some of the crafts come from. There is some kind of patriarchy most of the time, but in some periods and places women actually can earn money, own stuff, do business in their own name. That not being fully case in 1950 America is purely result of politics. That not being case in Saudi Arabia is purely gender ideology and politics, nothing to do with anything material.
- matthewmacleod 4y agoThere's nothing inherently wrong or problematic with a stay-at-home lifestyle if that's what you prefer and you can afford it. This is quite literally the viewpoint of all progressive politics, ever.