3 ms·
The critical factor is always publicity, rather than distribution models. Louis didn't get publicity because he put stuff on the internet, but rather because h
by toyg 15y ago
The critical factor is always publicity, rather than distribution models.
Louis didn't get publicity because he put stuff on the internet, but rather because he had built a following with his previous work, and used that to publicize this effort. He could have spent three months in a glass box suspended on the Hudson river and sold the tape at some random street market, and he would have probably received the same amount of money and attention.
The OP knows this very well, and is actually just trying to get publicity by arbitrarily linking his dad's stuff with Louis' name. To be honest, it's quite disgraceful.
- jnbiche 15y agoSo Louis C.K. riffs on the online world's hatred of DRM, and it's cool, but a fellow programmer riffs on Louis C.K.'s success to help his street-performing musician dad, and it's disgraceful? I think both are cool.
- toyg 15y agoCool, yes; newsworthy, not really: people have been doing this since 2002 at least. The newsworthy factor for Louis was about a big comedian deserting the old distribution model, something that had mostly been done before only in the music world (Radiohead, Trent Reznor, etc etc). (Even the, it got much more publicity than it really deserved, but that's the magic of showbiz for you.) But this? This is a nobody uploading mp3s on the net. Is this new? No. Is this hacker-related? No. Is this Louis-related? No. It's just a marketing trick. What next, "hey Hacker News, here's my store selling potatoes directly on the internet, I'm doing it like amazon" ?
- EGreg 15y agoLouis CK's experiment was hailed by many people as a proof that independent artists can produce themselves and distribute their stuff successfully using the net. What is disgraceful about making an experiment to see if it would work for a non-celebrity?
- georgemcbay 15y agoI agree that this isn't disgraceful at all, but for me the more interesting test will actually be whether or not Louis CK's model will work for other famous live performers. Did it work because the model is inherently sound or because it was so novel? I don't think we can say one way or the other yet. If I had to guess, I'd say that I think that his model will work for others but probably not as well, once (if?) it becomes commonplace I suspect you'll get a higher ratio of downloaders who don't pay to those that do.
- jakejake 15y agoThe fact that Louis CK released his material this way would not be interesting were it not for the fact that he could more easily have released it through "traditional" distribution. He has done great work, built up an audience and so there are studio/network buyers ready to pay him an advance for the rights to his material. The thing nobody gives studios and labels credit for is that they assume the financial risk on productions by advancing the money and then they profit handsomely (or lose money, which happens often). Louis CK decided to take this risk on himself. From what I've read it was about a quarter million of his own dollars on the entire production and distribution system. It seems genius in hindsight, but be didn't known that this was going to work so it took some balls. That's what makes it awesome and interesting in my opinion. For an unknown person to do this is not especially interesting because they have no real audience and no labels or networks waiting to hand over a cash advance to them. There is no real risk involved at all - it's simply the case of a musician trying to get their name out there and using the cheapest (and most likely only) option they have available to them. Though, I did give it a listen so it worked to some degree of getting your father some exposure. I say congrats on doing whatever you can to get exposure, there is no shame in that at all.