3 ms·
Ask HN: Does treating analog components as blackbox make sense?
Hi friends,
I have been playing with electronics on and off for a while but never went deep or made anything with anything.
A minute ago I got a revelation: as a hobbyist who is more into digital than analog, I don't need to understand each component. I only need to know things such as, OK I have an electric signal (voltage for example) and I need to bend it a bit or smooth it a bit, so I need certain analog components to make it happen, and I can always play with the values to make the curves look like the way I want.
What I'm trying to say is to throw away the formulas and treat them as Lego blocks or blackboxes. I have an input and I need the output to be of certain value and shape, so I piece together some blocks and make it happen. That's it.
Does it make sense to you? To clarify I had no education on analog electronics and only read a few chapters about them.
- richardjam73 4y agoAnalog components affect those around them which is why I always preferred digital electronics.
- markus_zhang 4y agoIf that's the case, does that mean I cannot simply treat them as independent blackboxes as they affect each other?
- abyesilyurt 4y agoYou can treat an analog component as black box if it has very high input impedance and very low output impedance. Generally the digital components satisfy this constraint.
- markus_zhang 4y agoThanks, I just think it's an idea to simplify my study (so that I don't really care too much about formulas)