3 ms·
I think you (and perhaps the GP) might have it backward. It isn't that Zigbee is so much better for local control, it's that it's a lot more work to do cloud c
by kelnos 4y ago
I think you (and perhaps the GP) might have it backward. It isn't that Zigbee is so much better for local control, it's that it's a lot more work to do cloud control with Zigbee, as you need a separate hub with... you guessed it, WiFi.
And customers want cloud control, it seems, and don't seem to care about the security and privacy issues around it. So why build two separate devices (the smart device + the hub) when you can just build a single device (the smart device) and put the WiFi directly in it? Sure, there might be a cost difference in the case where the customers might have many smart devices (many cheap Zigbee devices + one "expensive" hub vs. many "expensive" WiFi devices), but I'm not convinced the cost is all that different overall.
The main issue I do see is power consumption. It's much easier to make a battery-powered Zigbee (or Z-Wave) device where the customer won't have to change the batteries every few months. WiFi is a power hog compared to Zigbee/Z-Wave, even if you assume that the device (or at least its radio) will sleep a significant part of the time. But many of these smart devices end up being hard-wired, so often it isn't that big a deal. (To be fair, though, I have a WiFi battery-powered smart/keypad lock in a rental property, and its batteries last 9-12 months, so even the power consumption issue is often not much of an issue!)
Beyond that, if a company is going to put WiFi in their device, most of the more "mainstream" vendors are going to have it connect directly to their cloud service, and not bother with local control, except possibly as a fallback when internet access is down. That fallback is nice, when implemented, but for those of us who don't trust these vendors to secure their backends, the "cloud service by default" attitude is a liability. At least with Zigbee/Z-Wave, I know that it's local-only-by-default.
So to summarize: WiFi gives a better UX for customers, and is probably cheaper, too.
Personally I buy only Z-Wave kit for the smart devices in our primary home, connected to my custom-built hub, and don't allow a third-party to manage (and probably screw up) the cloud control bits. It's definitely more work to manage, and troubleshoot when there are issues. Certainly not suitable for your average homeowner.