4 ms·
He absolutely hits the nail on the head, wrt the reasons we can't have any type of backdoor -ever. Hate to be the one to tell the global law enforcement commun
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
He absolutely hits the nail on the head, wrt the reasons we can't have any type of backdoor -ever.
Hate to be the one to tell the global law enforcement community this, but, apparently, they seem to be entirely ignorant of it.
People have been having untapped correspondence between each other since the dawn of language. That's THOUSANDS OF YEARS. Long before Signal.
All they do, is meet, or drop communications, in any of ten thousand different ways, to each other.
It could be a thumb drive, or it could be two people, idly scratching the dirt (one of the stories behind the Christian "fish").
- DavideNL 4y ago> "People have been having untapped correspondence between each other since the dawn of language. That's THOUSANDS OF YEARS." Well, not from Amsterdam to New York with less than a second delay, or to an audience of billions of people. (I'm not judging about whether the creation of backdoors is good or bad, just saying that's a bad argument.)
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoBe nice. It’s not a “bad argument,” at all. Like most of these things, it’s simply a matter of degree and scale. “Less than a second” is just a fairly “fuzzy” quantitative statement, that can have many meanings, and can be scoped to encompass many datasets. For example, in the early 1900s, the telegraph system allowed people to send “BLACK COW NOW” across thousands of miles. If the two parties involved, have decided that this means “The President is a Jackass,” then, congratulations, we’ve used cryptographic communication to send subversive, anti-government messages. The telegraph system may take an hour or so (allowing for morse code translation), which is far less than the several months/weeks than it would take, via Pony Express. Amsterdam to New York, might actually take a half a second, depending on latency, and whatnot. Amsterdam to the moon, might take an order of magnitude more. If we had quantum communications working, then that might be truly instantaneous. Where’s the threshold? At what point do we decide that “the rules have changed?” Was Pheidippides an encrypted communication packet, when he delivered the news of the victory at Marathon in a few hours (he was certainly a “read-only” packet, as he dropped dead, after delivering the news)? What about the Enigma machine? That was combined with radio communications, to allow highly encrypted data exchange. Even with Turing, et al, what really gave us Enigma, was capturing a functioning unit on a German sub. It was a really tight system. It should be noted that hundreds of people died, during the war, because we did not want to give away the fact that Enigma was cracked, and allowed several attacks to proceed without interception. That's because we knew that, if the bad guys were aware that their communication medium was compromised, they would simply use another one, that we had not cracked (like the Navajo Code Talkers, on our side). Sound familiar? It’s really all just a numbers game. There's nothing new, here.