3 ms·
I think we are giving the government and Obama far too much credit for being stupid/naive/uncunning. Of course the NDAA funding auth is going to be passed. It
by samstave 15y ago
I think we are giving the government and Obama far too much credit for being stupid/naive/uncunning.
Of course the NDAA funding auth is going to be passed. It must be - thus, they throw on insidious clauses like the detainment, and Obama is the lucky guy who just happens to be in the unfortunate position where he must sign it even though he opposed certain items.
Here is an idea: require all laws to be single subject, single focus. If it is a funding measure, it cannot expand powers/modify any existing laws other than to either increase or decrease funding. If it is a law, such as one that is focused on the detainment of [whomever] then that should be a singular law stating under which circumstances this law shall be applied.
This is the number one source of corruption in the government, the ability to abuse the structure of the legal system.
By doing this one thing, you will cripple lobbying, create transparency and create accountability (you'll be able to understand where each rep is on each issue)
- e2e8 15y agoYou make sound like the administration did not want the powers granted by the bill. This is incorrect. The administration initially opposed the language because they believed it restricted powers they already had to detain indefinatly. "the authorities granted by the Authorization for Use of Military Force Against Terrorists, including the detention authority, are essential to our ability to protect the American people... Because the authorities codified in this section already exist, the Administration does not believe codification is necessary and poses some risk."
- samstave 15y agoNo, I am saying the administration is expertly farking with public perception. I am aware of their want to ensure their power was protected. I am saying that most people are being played to think that obmama expressed "concerns" but was painted into a corner where he needed to sign this. The fact is they ADDED / ENSURED the clauses they wanted were in there, then played the perception of the signage to make it look like they were the VICTIM rather than the perp. There is a very very good reason obama is a constitutional lawyer as potus. Hint: it is not to ensure your freedoms.
- jkn 15y ago"Here is an idea: require all laws to be single subject, single focus." The problem is that this goes against a parliament's ability to make deals. Each party has its own priorities, and is willing to compromise on other issues to advance these priorities. Putting unrelated laws in one bill is essentially a way of formalizing a compromise so that congress can vote on it (with time a complexifying factor that can serve both sides depending on the situation). Do you really want to take this away?