4 ms·
In a sense, this is a “process” film, devoted to the nuts and bolts of creation, and thus one of Cronenberg’s densest and most pedantic outings. Yet it’s someho
by bee_rider 4y ago
In a sense, this is a “process” film, devoted to the nuts and bolts of creation, and thus one of Cronenberg’s densest and most pedantic outings. Yet it’s somehow also among his most immediate works—a kind of intellectual road map for the contemplation of existential questions of such overwhelming scale and urgency that few artists dare to confront them so directly.
Does anyone know what a process film is, or what it means for a movie to be pedantic?
I can’t make heads or tails of this, but I’m glad (sincerely and unsarcastically) that Cronenberg is around to make movies for people who can!
- slibhb 4y agoYou don't have to intellectualize movies to enjoy them.
- bee_rider 4y agoI agree. Some people enjoy movies more by intellectualizing them, though, and certain directors seem to have more to offer them.
- pessimizer 4y agoI suspect that by "process" film, they mean a film about the process of doing something.
- autoexec 4y agoI'm guessing a process film is this: In The Process Genre Salomé Aguilera Skvirsky introduces and theorizes the process genre—a heretofore unacknowledged and untheorized transmedial genre characterized by its representation of chronologically ordered steps in which some form of labor results in a finished product. https://www.dukeupress.edu/the-process-genre https://www.dukeupress.edu/the-process-genre a 'pedantic film' may just mean it's unimaginative/boring, or even ostentatious/preachy
- Slow_Hand 4y agoCrikey. The writing from that excerpt is tedious to parse. Why is academic writing so often insufferable? Are there any other genres of writing that are usually this clunky to read? Maybe legal writing?
- autoexec 4y agoSorry, I didn't author it, I just found it googling around for an explanation for the term. I blame the publisher.
- MrVandemar 4y ago> Why is academic writing so often insufferable? * partially professional domain nomenclature (like programmers talking about Log O2N efficiency); * probably also defining or adhering to some kind of academic cultural exclusivity, in the same way that managers use ghastly business vernacular with "action items" and "synergy", or military langauge that is heavy with code words and TLAs, or even casual street slang like: "Yo, 'sup dawg?". Comprehension is because you are in the "in group", or at least you are signalling that you belong to that group Kind of interesting phenomenon, until you have to try to meaningfully communicate with a Manager/Marketing Person/Sales Person, at which point you can't believe you're talking to an alleged human being and wonder desperately how you can make them leave you alone.
- yamtaddle 4y agoThe sentence tells you exactly what "'process' film" means—"devoted to the nuts and bolts of creation", that is, to a process. The quotes on "process" here indicate the author is either using some very-obscure term or (more likely, I think) is coining it themselves for their purpose in this piece, which is why (in either case) it's explained right after. Pedantic, I think is used in the sense of schoolmasterly or in the manner of a teacher—as in: the film "reads" a bit like a lecture, is concerned with details and plainly connecting A to B in a logical order and clearly demonstrating that to the viewer, that kind of thing. That's why it's contrasted with "Yet it’s somehow also among his most immediate works" (emphasis mine). The author's saying it's not also excessively abstract or distant from life and applicability, as one imagines lectures might sometimes be. Same root as "pedagogy", though outside certain educated circles "pedant" is almost exclusively used in the colloquial, pejorative sense of "know-it-all, especially one who insists on correcting others unnecessarily"—but it's certainly used in the older, more neutral sense here.
- sdwr 4y agoI read process as meaning the film is about systemic effects in a variety of contexts, as opposed to being plot- or character- driven. Like, "it's about the journey, not the destination", but one step further, because journey implies people and meaningful events.
- RC_ITR 4y agoPedantic in this case means dull and unimaginative. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/pedantic https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/pedantic Everyone else’s understanding of process seems fine.
- HillRat 4y ago"Pedantic" is probably not the most felicitous term they could have used; they clearly meant something more like "abstruse," given their obvious admiration for the film.
- bee_rider 4y agoLater the interviewer describes his own questions as pedantic. Accusations of pedantry are thrown around so often, (sometimes incorrectly) that perhaps it is gaining a new less derogatory meaning, something like “precise.”
- bee_rider 4y agoI’ve gotten multiple contradictory definitions of “process film” here, I think yamtaddle’s is most correct though. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34177435 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34177435
- abruzzi 4y agoI read it as like a “police procedural”, which is a film that prioritizes the actual procedure of police work over big themes, character development, and action. In this case—-it delves into processes, artistic and bureaucratic. There are “big themes” but there are also odd scenes where bureaucrats discuss the need for cataloging organs, and artists discuss the viability of doing an autopsy as art. In this quote I read “pedantic” as simply meaning focused on the details, really just a reinforcement of the “process” assertion.