3 ms·
Human infants are not meant to sleep alone, and human parents are not meant to care for babies all by themselves- especially not one exhausted mother all on her
by fallingfrog 4y ago
Human infants are not meant to sleep alone, and human parents are not meant to care for babies all by themselves- especially not one exhausted mother all on her own. Evolutionarily speaking we are supposed to be surrounded by extended family, who can hold the baby and give mom and dad a chance to sleep. It's just the cruelty of modern industrial society that makes people resort to such things as leaving a baby all alone. Future generations are going to see these practices as tragic and the fact that we don't support new parents leads to stressed out, insecure babies, or worse.
Here's the truth: nothing works. They just eventually grow out of it. When they are a year or two old, you can start transitioning to having them sleep by themselves.
I really did try to sleep train my youngest.. I would set a timer and not let her go too long. I really tried. Once I went and picked her up after 15 minutes, and her little voice had grown hoarse. She was covered in sweat and shaking and she just collapsed against me when I picked her up. Her tiny body, just limp against me. She had nothing left. And she whimpered softly. Babies aren't meant to sleep alone. I wish I had someone I could call. One hour of sleep would have meant everything.
- cycrutchfield 4y agoThis line of reasoning is absurd. We do a lot of things we aren’t “meant” to do evolutionarily. Babies can and do sleep alone just fine. Sorry it didn’t work out in your case, but don’t try to appeal to Evolution to rationalize it to yourself.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 4y agoIs it absurd? I think your statement is a bit too strong given what the OP has described: that seems a really painful experience for a parent. There is the possibility that it is an evolutionary trait of some subset of the population: some children might not be able to sustain sleep training and others might be. So your statement is extreme too: it's entirely possible that some human beings are not made for that and others are. The only certainty we have is that humans need physical contact when they are babies, we don't know how much is enough from a scientific point though (and I doubt we would be able to do any experiment related to that ever again)