3 ms·
> There are plenty people in the world doing jobs that are boring, even to them, but they don't care because they can make a living, and that's the important th
by mschuster91 4y ago
> There are plenty people in the world doing jobs that are boring, even to them, but they don't care because they can make a living, and that's the important thing.
I see it the other way around... why do we keep people in such boring (or to use the official term, bullshit) jobs when we could automate away as much as we reasonably can and enjoy maybe a 20 hour work week or not work at all?! How much productivity, how much talent could we unlock from our society if people weren't wasting their potential away for something a computer can do faster and with infinitely better accuracy?
- uoaei 4y agoAgreed. Something to remember is, what people do with their free time is also economic activity. Usually they consume, but sometimes they also produce (arts, crafts, trades, etc.). These outputs have measurable effects on quality of life and local economic health. Not everything has to be filtered through the narrow lens of waged employment to contribute to the commonwealth.
- miguelazo 4y agoPerhaps 20 years ago, this comment wouldn't have landed as a joke to me. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/36696533-new-dark-age https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/36696533-new-dark-age
- mschuster91 4y agoThe problem is not technology, the problem is that we (and in particular, the Boomer generation that was in power of society for the last 30 years) stood idle while democratic control of society was ceded to ever larger private entities piece by piece. We could live in a world where technology serves the people so that we get back to the 20 hour work week that medieval peasants enjoyed - now, technology serves the ultra-rich elites (either as playthings or to further their interests) and increasingly repressive surveillance state governments, and unions have lost more and more influence.
- miguelazo 4y agoI used to think that as well, and I still agree that the root problem is neoliberalism, if not capitalism itself. But as long as they remain the dominant system, technology will be developed in service to their ends. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/60299346-scorched-earth https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/60299346-scorched-earth
- gnarbarian 4y agoI think people need work. even meaningless work. It forces us to get out of bed in the morning and provides a crystallizing point for organizing our lives. beyond that, I think people need to feel like they have a purpose or serve a function even if minimal.
- mschuster91 4y agoPeople will work nevertheless - they just will do work unappreciated by capitalism: they will raise children (a large part of why birth rates have dropped is because it's absolutely impossible to raise children on two or more full time jobs), they will get into creative work (make music or art, write books, ...), they will take care of their elderly again instead of shoving them into "care homes", they will create open-source software, they will be managing their investments, they will work in whatever form of charity... > It forces us to get out of bed in the morning I'm European, even when I have vacation (yes, we actually have vacation) I still regularly get up out of bed. Medieval peasants also got out of bed.
- chasebank 4y agoI'd bet that most people, in fact, would sit on the couch and do nothing if given the chance. Most people are lazy. Most people are fat. Most people will take the path of least resistance and just do nothing. Medieval peasants didn't have television, internet and video games to isolate them. Humans are social creatures. As much as HN loves working remote, for most people, especially introverts, I'd wager it's terrible for their longterm health and mental state.
- mschuster91 4y ago> I'd bet that most people, in fact, would sit on the couch and do nothing if given the chance. The data on UBI experiments [1] suggest that you may well lose the bet. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_basic_income_pilots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_basic_income_pilots
- ornornor 4y ago
- m463 4y agoremember whatever a computer can do for you, it can do to you.
- jsrcout 4y agoI agree completely. But IMO the inevitable result is going to be "we" (whoever that is) automating those jobs away, and "them" (the former workers) finding themselves that much closer to the edge of survival without benefiting in any way. A Universal Basic Income, or something else equally broad and dependable, would go far to mitigate this issue for displaced workers. But who's going to pay for it? "Not me!" is the most common answer to that question. At least, that's my cynical take from studying history and reading the news for way too many years.
- rolenthedeep 4y agoMy bet is that menial jobs like this will be automated away in the next few decades, but if/when it stops being necessary to work to live, these jobs will come back. Think of it like a hobby. At a base level, people need something to keep their minds and bodies busy with. Some guys build massive elaborate train sets, and others become the singular world expert in stocking candy in a London train station.