3 ms·
> What happens when most "people" you interact with on the internet are fake? I think people start logging off. I don't necessarily think that's the case. Reme
by pavel_lishin 4y ago
> What happens when most "people" you interact with on the internet are fake? I think people start logging off.
I don't necessarily think that's the case. Remember the old "nobody on the internet knows you're a dog" cartoon? Well, I think that for a lot of things, nobody cares if they're talking to a dog.
People only care about people on the internet being fake in certain contexts. They'll very much care if all of their dating app matches are robots, because the end goal of a dating app is actually meeting someone in the flesh.
But I don't think that people on Nextdoor and Facebook groups particularly care - or would even notice - if they're talking to robots. As far as I can tell from my limited exposure, most people like getting caremad in comments. Even in local groups, it doesn't feel like there's much connection being made between neighbors; an AI complaining about traffic or agreeing/disagreeing with someone's political opinion would scratch the same itch as someone two towns over doing it.
- peteradio 4y agoDoes it matter if the person on the other side of the glory hole is a dude? Maybe? Maybe you didn't think that was a possibility? Maybe it being widely known that you are yelling at clouds makes it less satisfying of a scratch?
- nothis 4y agoOk, that's worse.
- jlarocco 4y agoThere's a lot of "I don't think" in there. Have you actually asked anybody? I haven't, but my impression and anecdotal data is exactly opposite.
- burnished 4y agoPicking at “I don’t think” feels like point scoring behavior, and generally unwise - we want people to share their confidence level and source right? Dropping it makes your argument harder to nitpick and sound more authoritative at the expense of important information/honesty. Suggested remediation: just, like, disagree :) this is a self serving recommendation though because I really enjoy seeing people’s differing perspectives
- spaceman_2020 4y agoSome of the most popular platforms online are largely anonymous (Reddit and Twitter). Most of the time, you don’t even notice the username of the person responding to you. They might as well be bots, but people don’t care. Heck, Reddit threads are often so predictable that they might as well be written by bots. So yeah, most people just want to talk and feel that someone, something is listening to them. People rejecting your idea need to recalibrate their understanding of the depth and breadth of human loneliness. The original New Yorker cartoonist forgot that people talk to their dogs too.
- WindyLakeReturn 4y agoI don't think they care who it is, but they care who is a who. They aren't concerned about it being an AI because that concern hasn't crossed their mind. If it becomes common knowledge that the people responding are bots, I think we will see others begin to react. I've seen similar reaction in communities around enjoying art, even though I find those have less reason to care where the art comes from.
- pavel_lishin 4y agoAs a member of one of those communities, I definitely have a good reason to care - AI art has flooded some of them, to the point where it's all "noise", and there's not much value in reading things until it dies down.