3 ms·
> I'd be happy to pay a fee to become a member of a community with vetted participants You better start believing in vetted online communities Miss Turner, yo
by moffkalast 4y ago
> I'd be happy to pay a fee to become a member of a community with vetted participants
You better start believing in vetted online communities Miss Turner, you're in one!
It may not be vetting by moderators, but HN's dated frontend definitely acts as a forcefield against many kinds of people.
- _as31 4y agoI feel like Lobsters has better quality discourse nowadays though, due to its much more explicit vetting system. I am not part of that website, yet I love reading the comment section there.
- citizenkeen 4y agoWhat is this? My Google-fu is weak.
- moffkalast 4y agolobste.rs is what I can find. Likely tries to make its SEO as bad as possible to avoid discovery, which is kinda funny.
- nataz 4y agoWas lobster.rs ways invite only? I thought I remembered having an account a long time ago...but my email isn't registered when I go to reset my PW. Because it's a much smaller community it does suffer from low comment counts on posts. Comments are the best part of HN.
- jakewins 4y agoInvite only to write, open to read. But the main trick is tracking the invite tree - if the person that invited you gets banned, you get banned too (or need to appeal to have your “branch” of the invite tree adopted by someone else).
- mikewarot 4y agoSo if jcs somehow gets banned, the whole place shuts down? I find the idea of the site intriguing yet I'm not sure what I could contribute.
- arthurcolle 4y agoIt is largely the same as HN
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoExcept HN is a mix of tech-bro entrepreneur types and developers, whereas the other site is exclusively developers (with an emphasis on open source).
- throw10920 4y agojcs started the site, so him getting banned would be quite a feat indeed! (although it would be an amusing way to shut the site down if he gets tired of maintaining it...)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nerdbert 4y agoJust looked at lobsters and there are zero comments on almost all posts.
- sangnoir 4y agoQ.E.D.
- im3w1l 4y agoSigned up day one with a one char username. Tried to use it a few years later and by then it had been deleted. Understandable I guess, but I'm still salty about it. Just had to get that story off my chest.
- kruxigt 4y ago[dead]
- monksy 4y agoReddit when they had their old frontend and bad mobile expierence was much better than it is now.
- burnished 4y agoGenuinely, what do you see as dated? My only other point of comparison is Reddit so I suspect I’m behind the times.
- altairprime 4y agoDo you use old or new interface?
- burnished 4y agoOld, I think? I saw a friends and his was this stream of pictures and gifs, whereas mine is entirely titles with the occasional thumb nail.
- altairprime 4y agoThat would be the “dated” interface, then. I prefer it too.
- moffkalast 4y agoMainly the interaction (though the graphical design itself definitely isn't what you'd call modern). No notifications or gui animations, no thumbnails or header images, being as hard to navigate as possible, scroll position gets reset all the time, can't even reply to a comment while looking at the rest of the thread because everything is its own separate page, nothing has outlines so text has no clear separation, etc. In a nutshell it feels like a site made in the 90s entirely with HTML forms without a line of javascript. I mean I do absolutely hate the new reddit redesign and almost exclusively use old.reddit, but the functionality there is still on another level when compared to HN.
- Sebb767 4y ago> scroll position gets reset all the time Actually, HN is the only social media site where my browser can consistently keep the scroll position. Animations and endless scrolling are what breaks it.