7 ms·
> Same with “plant-based cookie”—does that mean no animal butter, but yes to eggs? An egg isn't the fruit of a plant; of course it's not plant-based if it cont
by kazinator 4y ago
> Same with “plant-based cookie”—does that mean no animal butter, but yes to eggs?
An egg isn't the fruit of a plant; of course it's not plant-based if it contains eggs.
Everyone should be irked, regardless of their political alignment in the area of food, if they are told that something with eggs is plant-based. It is a mistake or misrepresentation.
Plant-based can only possibly mean that it's made from leaves, stalks, fruits, nuts, seeds, bark, roots or any other part of a plant.
If it contains mushrooms, yeasts or fungi, it's not plant-based; those are not plants. However, I would be generous in that if some plant comes with certain naturally occurring bacteria or fungi, then something made with that plant can still be plant-based. If the plant material is fermented, confirming bacteria or moulds, let's say it can be plant-based anyway. Insects have to be removed, though.
- mytailorisrich 4y ago"Plant-based" does not imply uniquely made of plants as per the dictionnary definition of 'based'. That's an issue with the term, which is fuzzy and aimed at marketing.
- Aaargh20318 4y agoThis. I interpret "plant-based" as "plants are the majority of the mass of the product."
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoSure, though it still feels a little sneaky, clearly the majority of a cookie that contains eggs and butter is still wheat... It reminds me a little more of packaging that proclaims that a box of table salt is "fat-free!" or a box of sugar is "gluten-free!" - well, yes, I'd hope so, since you'd have to go out of your way to add those in...
- scatters 4y ago> you'd have to go out of your way to add those in And yet food companies are adding minimal amounts of peanut oil or sesame flour to products, specifically so they don't have to guarantee that they are free of those allergens.
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoWell, those two aren't quite the same, otherwise they'd be adding them to EVERYTHING they make. I was reacting to the duplicity of claiming something was free of an ingredient that would never be present, where choosing to add an allergen because it's cheaper than paying to prove it isn't present is a perverse outcome of well-intentioned regulations + cut-throat corporations.
- aradox66 4y agoFungus foods are absolutely considered "plant-based" in the way this term is used. It just means "not-animal". Spirulina, chlorella, blue-algae would also definitely qualify.