3 ms·
I thought I was good at scrabble but then I realized that playing against my parents does not count. Experts just memorize dictionaries. Just anther example of
by paulpauper 4y ago
I thought I was good at scrabble but then I realized that playing against my parents does not count. Experts just memorize dictionaries. Just anther example of a game that has been optimized. Would not surprise me if we see a cheating scandal similar to professional chess.
- TylerE 4y agoAt one point the top S rabble player in, iirc French or German was an American who didn’t speak the language. Just pure memorization
- nathell 4y agoIt was French, and Nigel Richards is not American but from New Zealand.
- viraptor 4y agoI come back from time to time to the thought of how exactly to define the threshold where games are fun while you're still improving. I hate playing with people who take the experience professionally, but having some strategy involved is definitely fun.
- sh4rks 4y agoIn my opinion, games are the most fun when you're playing against someone slightly higher than your skill level.
- joshvm 4y agoI think the most interesting thing about competitive Scrabble is that it's not really about memorising dictionaries. Once you assume that everyone knows every playable word, the real distinction is in the tactics. There's elements of statistics to determine what your opponent is likely to have, whether to play offensively or defensively, etc. It's a very different game to "family" Scrabble, but we always had the etiquette rule that you should know the definition of a word you played. It isn't enough to know it's in the Scrabble dictionary.
- nathell 4y agoI play Polish Scrabble competitively, and IME there’s much more to the game than just memorizing the dictionary. A program that has full knowledge of the dictionary and always plays the highest-scoring word will easily yield to a human. There’s virtually no strategy, but tactics is of paramount importance. Things like keeping your rack balanced; which one of several similarly-scoring words to play, based on your knowledge of the game state; when and what to exchange, etc. These factors are all at play very much intuitively, and are learnt with practice over the years. Polish is especially fun to play because it’s highly inflected, meaning that: - the number of unique words in the dictionary is about one order of magnitude greater than in, say, English or French – it’d be much harder for Nigel Richards to learn them all; - keeping an eye on certain combinations of letters (that might form an inflective ending) is much more important. Plus, there’s a small but vibrant community, with its very own history and folklore to be proud of. :)
- AeroNotix 4y agoMy wife is Polish and we tried playing the Polish Scrabble. Allowing for English or Polish words. Took me a few games of getting trounced to realise the letter set is completely different in the Polish version.
- dmurray 4y agoComputers are better than humans at Scrabble [0], so the possibility exists for cheating even if their advantage doesn't stem only from mastery of the dictionary. [0] I don't know how much better - but Maven was considered better than the best humans in 2002, and in most such pursuits, machines have improved faster than humans since then https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0004370201001667 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000437020...
- zem 4y agomaven was decidedly not better than the best humans, and even today the best humans are better than the best AI players out there, though the gap is narrowing.
- scotty79 4y agoNice games are the ones where rules or some important factors are modifiable. The way we played Quake was by taking hundreds of user made maps and playing them one by one untill they got stale. It's completely different way of playing than what modern games do. Basically learning just a handful of maps by heart up to specific timings, sound and few pixel spots. Basically rigidifying naturally variable parts of the game to make it more boring and repetitive for the sake of creating controlled conditions of competition.
- zem 4y agoscrabble cheating scandals have typically involved palming tiles, not computer assistance