3 ms·
Democracy is not the unique product of the Western civilization. The unique product is a trifecta of ideas: - Human self-determination: humans (after all sexua
by nine_k 4y ago
Democracy is not the unique product of the Western civilization. The unique product is a trifecta of ideas:
- Human self-determination: humans (after all sexual, racial. xenophobic, etc biases) have the right to determine their own fate. Ideas of personal freedom, equality, and democracy follow from it, among other things, like free enterprise and markets.
- Science, in a broad sense: the desire to study how the word works, for fun and profit, through the reality itself, thus doubting any preconceptions, traditions, etc. This of course had and still has many culture-induced limitations, but generally it's considered a worthy thing to do and to share.
- Universalism: all humans are worthy enough (again, after all sexual, racial. xenophobic, etc biases), so the two ideas above are not limited to one blessed tribe that should not care about anyone else; the ideas should be spread.
Any two without a third don't seem to be enough to put a civilization onto an upwards spiral of accumulation and spreading of knowledge and material wealth. (The scary thought of many a sci-fi writer is that the first idea is not actually required, or can be extinguished later.)
Other civilizations, which did not concentrate on accumulating of material wealth or written knowledge as much as the West, achieved serious heights in other areas, often quite higher than what the West was able to achieve by that time. But they could not withstand the clash, and were often destroyed, or, in a slightly more fortunate turn of events, assimilated.
- Psychlist 4y agoTo paraphrase Ghandi's famous quote: get back to me in 10,000 years and I'll have an opinion on whether western civilisation works. I live in a country where recorded history goes back 15,000+ years and there's evidence for continuous culture for 30,000 years or more. "caring for country" is just wildly incompatible with even "ancient greek*" ideals but only one of them can say it's worked for 10,000 years. * you know when a four year old kid says "you're really old". That's us looking at Ancient Greece
- RandomLensman 4y agoDepends what "worked" means. Is your country that much richer, e.g., higher GDP per head than most countries? By some other measures? Different societies might chose different objective functions and then comparing what works is tricky. Especially, if being around in a certain cultural form isn't a strong part of the objective.
- wahern 4y agoI don't think "Western culture" can have much meaning going back more than 2 or 3 millennia at the most. And I suspect that's true of every identifiable culture around the globe, at least the large and complex ones--smaller, isolated ones may be more stable. Go back to the first millennium BC and you can find the roots of Western culture in Northern India, Persia, the Middle East, North and even Central Africa, and elsewhere at least as much as they can be found in Europe. And vice-versa--Buddhist and Hindu religious sculpture, for example, was strongly influenced by Greek art. If you're looking across 10,000 years, the histories of much of Eurasia and Africa are intertwined in ways that make our modern categories useless. OTOH, an argument could be made that an expansive definition of "Western culture" could be inclusive of much of Eurasia and Africa, especially when you look at major religions. Though they often have wildly different answers, most of them are asking similar questions--e.g. the problem of evil. To find cultures (or clusters of cultures or what have you) which consistently ask fundamentally different questions you have to go further afield.
- wahern 4y agoWestern scholars are also pretty good at creating straw men and selling contrarian, reductionist social theories that deftly project their own value systems onto other groups even while claiming the opposite. That aptitude is readily explained by your distinguishing points.
- llanowarelves 4y agoIndeed. The West's constituents on average are the least in-group preferential, and incorrectly assume that non-Westerners are the same. And they assume that non-Westerners value the same civilizational values like Truth over (Social) Face, Truth over Harmony, etc. as much as they do. Ironically, those not from the West, let's say a developing African country, will appreciate the West's (relatively) high trust (Japan would be moreso) and less clannish (more meritocratic) nature for doing business and growing wealth in a whole lot more than almost anyone born in the West (who take deep social values as a given for all humans. which is just them optimistically projecting, it's not ill-willed).