2 ms·
> the main disadvantage of Abe et al.’s design is that it is an over-actuated mechanism: it requires four instead of only three actuators. In this paper, we pro
by hinkley 4y ago
> the main disadvantage of Abe et al.’s design is that it is an over-actuated mechanism: it requires four instead of only three actuators. In this paper, we propose a variation on this mechanism which requires three actuators, thus simplifying its control and its potential cost.
That’s sort of the problem. Four motors and nine gears, versus three motors and six gears. I suspect their solution here may be as simple as having two rolling motors at angles, and only one motor for twisting.
- jacquesm 4y agoI once designed a mirror array to track the sun and reflect the image on a solar panel to get more concentrated power (solars cells = expensive, mirrors = cheap). Obviously there are all kinds of limits to that but the interesting part in the current context was the drive: it started off with two motors per mirror and in successive iterations that went to one motor per row of mirrors and one motor per column to one for all the rows and one for all the columns and finally a single motor for all of the mirrors. It was mostly my lack of understanding about the way the sun and the earth interact over time at the beginning of the project that caused me to choose the most naive solution, but as understanding increased I saw more and more ways to optimize the whole thing ending up with a set of gears that resemble the relationship between the two bodies pretty much in the same way that a planetarium would do, with the angles of the mirrors as the function of the time of day and the position of the earth in its orbit around the sun as well as the axis of tilt. That whole process took about a year and it looks to me as though this project is on a similar path of optimization, though it likely won't go much further than 3 motors, 4 gears assuming they can find a way to put the twist motor inside the spherical gear, which would come with its own challenges (supplying power, feedback).
- hinkley 4y agoI think it’s sufficient to do as they have done and use one motor to turn another motor, and for the third one, put the motor on bearings.