3 ms·
So, as someone who regularly visits B&N stores, this…creates a false narrative around the turnaround. Obviously, it has turned around, and is great. But it pret
by dragonwriter 4y ago
So, as someone who regularly visits B&N stores, this…creates a false narrative around the turnaround. Obviously, it has turned around, and is great. But it pretends that a sacrifice of floor space to non-book uses was part of the decline and the turnaround has involved recentering on books and particularly on a focus on intellectual stimulation, and the first is pretty clearly not true, and the second seems likely to be only in a very particular sense that diverges from what I think the average person reading the article would think.
On the first point, floor space devoted to books compared to the past at the same stores has continued to decline, with, in one case, the entire space formerly devoted to non-book items now devoted just to games and toys, and spaces that were, before the pandemic, devoted to books now devoted DVDs, vinyl records, and other legacy media.
On the second, the two sections of books that have not lost space seem to be (1) the bargain book section (which is also largely merchandised to show the whole fronts of books rather than spines like the rest of the store, so it is the least titles per unit of shelf space) and the self-help section; the rest of the sections have been compressed as the non-book areas have spread. If we define “intellectual stimulation” in terms of engaging a recurring customer base, I suppose that meets the description; but I don’t think it’s what people would normally read the description as implying.
I do think that the article, amidst the noise, identifies the key factor: giving stores control over stocking books that appeal to their customer base rather than relying on a mix of promotional agreements with publishers and HQ buyer selections. This leads to a selection more tailored to the local market, and more conservatively chosen – not in the political sense, but in the sense of what will sell vs. what publishers hope to make sell by placement.
- klelatti 4y ago> This leads to a selection more tailored to the local market, and more conservatively chosen – not in the political sense, but in the sense of what will sell vs. what publishers hope to make sell by placement. I know what you’re trying to say here - that local booksellers will play it more safe than publishers who might support a new author for example - but I think this is a mistaken perspective. First of all we are likely to see lots of small scale experiments where local booksellers will try different books based on their own instincts. That’s controlled risk taking and is likely to be less conservative than a global publisher. Then they will be closer to their actual readers and so will have a better understanding of what new books / authors will work for their actual customers. Finally this favours quality over other factors. If a local bookseller recommends a book they are putting their own credibility - and financial performance - on the line. They want readers to come back to their store rather than just sell that book.